Defendants shall be punished by imprisonment for one year.

However, as to the Defendants for three years from the date of the final judgment of this case.

Punishment of the crime

Defendants are Vietnamese foreigners.

If duty-free goods are purchased by credit card on an aircraft in operation, it cannot be immediately confirmed whether approval for the credit card is granted due to the limitation in the telecommunications technology system for operation of the aircraft.

The Defendants, along with Vietnam F (F and G), made the credit card issued in Vietnam under the name of the Defendants to be suspended from trading, using the restriction on the aviation navigation system as above. After the Defendants, the Defendants, on board the aircraft and purchased tax-free goods on the aircraft, offered as if they had been engaged in normal credit transactions with the credit card that cannot be settled normally due to the suspension of trading, and offered as if they had been issued tax-free goods and conspired to avoid the settlement of the price.

1. Defendant A, in collusion with F on August 5, 2015, purchased tax-free goods of five types, such as siren 30 years old by crew members on the name of selling the internal free goods in Asia and Asia, AO742, which started at the airport of Thailand around August 5, 2015 to Incheon International Airport, and purchased tax-free goods in the aircraft of 30 years old by using the name of crew members on the name of selling the internal free goods in the aircraft of 196,00,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000.