1. The plaintiff's respective claims against the defendants are dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.

1. Basic facts

A. The status of the party is as follows:

- The plaintiff: the representative director (from July 1, 1995 to the date) of the E-limited company located in Sejong Special Self-Governing City (hereinafter referred to as the "instant company") - Defendant B: the president of the Daejeon Northern Branch E Branch of the Korean Metal Trade Union (hereinafter referred to as the "Subdivision of this case"), the issuer of the "F" (hereinafter referred to as the "instant newsletter") who is the newsletter issued by the branch of this case, and Defendant C: the Daejeon Northern Branch G of the Korean Metal Trade Union.

B. The instant newsletter contains the following contents, and the bottom of the content is asserted by the Plaintiff, and the content of the instant newsletter is indicated voluntarily as is.

The newsletter of this case shall be distributed to a simple resting room, a middle resting room, a welfare club room, and a table table for meetings of producers in the factory in the company of this case.

(1) No. 16, publishing date H - - Finding a representative director at the office”, and the representative director at the office shouldered the principle of trust and good faith with metal labor.

Even the negotiation has not been present even.

It seems that the second union and the wind are difficult.

The representative director shall attend the negotiations.

In order not to participate in negotiations intentionally, it is the representative director's ability to speak in the quality expenses.

The representative director shall be present at the negotiations as soon as possible without any further appearance and shall be present at the negotiations.

(2) No. 36 of the instant newsletter, publishing date I - - ? Shall the representative director and the site be called as the Halime, the basic observance of the field that did not go beyond the Gun belt of the two arms years, and the codib (3) 44 of the instant newsletter, issuance date J - The date of issuance - the summons for the Korean Barun who was covered by the cap because of the quantity,” and the omission-representative were forced to wear the cap on the spot immediately on the spot.

The private side, as if he did not wear the mother and child, was far away from heading as he was the largest day, and this is against the owner of goods.