Defendants shall be punished by imprisonment for one year.

However, as to the defendants, the above two-year period from the date of this judgment became final and conclusive.

Punishment of the crime

[Status of the Defendants] Defendant A was appointed as a local administrative journal to the Myeon Office of Ansan-gun Office on August 1983, 1983, and was transferred to and from January 1, 1989, to E-Dong Office of Dong in D, and served as the head of Dong and team at D’s cleaning from May 30, 201 to March 9, 2014. The same year from March 10, 2014

9. From September 26, 2014 to September 25, 201, the head of the immediate response team at D’s civil petition and class 5 public officials serving as the head of the Dong of D City F from September 26, 2014.

Defendant

B passed the employment examination for indefinite contract workers at the time of D in 2016, and from January 2, 2017 to January 2, 2017, it is an inorganic contract worker who has been employed as an environmental U.S. worker and worked as an environment worker.

G is not only a person who is appointed as a policy assistant officer around May 10, 2015 and is in charge of planning to exercise overall control over the implementation and enforcement of core policies in the D city, but also a person who directly assists in the affairs of the D market and is in a position to exercise de facto influence over personnel affairs, employment, etc. of public officials belonging to D.

[Procedure for Employment of Inorganic Contract Workers at the time of D] In the case of employment of environmental U.S. workers at D, the first and second practical examinations are conducted, and the third practical examinations are conducted against those who passed the second practical examinations, and the second and third practical examinations are combined (40 points for the practical examination and 60 points for the interview) and the final successful candidates are determined in order of high-ranking candidates. In fact, there is no difference in the first and second practical examinations and there is no difference in the first and second practical examinations.

On the other hand, the three interview and interview officers consist of internal committee members and external committee members. The internal committee members shall be selected from the director of the department of class V or higher (with approximately 22 members) and the head of the Dong (six members) who belong to D, and the external committee members shall be selected from among the director of the department of class V or higher and the head of the Dong, such as retirement public officials and H Si, I Si, I, etc. in the case of the third interview with employment of the U.S. environmental committee members in 2016.