1. The Defendants: (a) from February 17, 2016 to February 18, 2016 to the Plaintiff each of the KRW 100,000 to the Plaintiff; and (b) Defendant D from February 18, 2016 to the Plaintiff.

1. The following facts are found either to be in dispute between the parties or to be recognized by comprehensively considering the overall purport of the pleadings in each entry in Gap evidence of No. 1 to 6 (including evidence with a serial number):

A. From February 2007, the Plaintiff operated an individual broadcasting station under the name of “K” as “L”, which is an Internet personal broadcasting service operated by J, a corporation from February 2, 2007.

B. A monthly broadcast that the Plaintiff proceeds from “M” is broadcast from 11 A.m. to 2 P.m., from T.m. to T.m., from T.m. to T.m., from T.m. to T.m., and re-broadcasting is broadcast during the remaining hours.

The number of viewers is 3,00 to 4,000 in the case of a protogram, and 1,000 in the case of a protogram, 300 to 600 in the case of a protogram, and 300 to 600 in the case of a protogram, and the Plaintiff’s address, telephone number, e-mail, etc. are disclosed on the screen of “M”.

C. The Defendants, after accessing K with each of the following IDs, posted the following articles on the hosting bank of “M”:

(♡는 성적 표현이나 욕설로서 금칙어에 해당되어 블라인드 처리된 것이다). 이 름 아이디 게시글 내용 일 자 B O “그래서 얘는 빨갱이임” 2016. 2. 17. D P “L 보♡지” “L이랑 ♡♡스하겜” 2016. 2. 18. G Q “진짜 빨갱이” 2016. 2. 19. H R “종북좌파빨갱이 물러가라! 좌/샤방/좀 척결!” “종북좌파빨갱이 물러가라! 좌/샤방/좀 척결!” “종북좌파빨갱이 물러가라! 좌/샤방/좀 척결!” “종북좌파빨갱이 물러가라! 좌/샤방/좀 척결!” “종북좌파빨갱이 물러가라! 좌/샤방/좀 척결!♡” “종북좌파빨갱이 물러가라! 좌/샤방/좀 척결!” “종북좌파빨갱이 물러가라! 좌/샤방/좀 척결!” “종북좌파빨갱이 물러가라! 좌/샤방/좀 척결!” “스샷 열심히혀라 빨갱아~~~” “종북좌파빨갱이 물러가라! 좌/샤방/좀 척결!”...