1. The Plaintiff:

A. As from October 14, 2015, Defendant B: 100,000 won and its related thereto:

B. Defendant C shall be KRW 100,000 and this shall apply.

1. Facts of recognition;

A. The Plaintiff operated a personal broadcasting station under the name of “F”, which is an Internet personal broadcasting service operated by F, and from February 2007, “G,” “G,” “B,” “B,” “I,” respectively.

B. The Plaintiff’s bio-broadcasting is broadcasted from 1:0 a.m. to 2:0 p.m. on Saturdays, from 11:0 p.m. to 2:0 p.m. on Tuesday to 5:0 p.m., and re-broadcasting is broadcast during the remaining hours.

The number of viewers is 3,00-4,000 in the case of a protogram, and 1,000 in the case of a protogram, and 300-60 in the case of a protogram, and 3,00-60 in the case of a protogram, and the address, telephone number, e-mail, etc. of the Plaintiff are disclosed on the top of “H”.

C. After having connected each other’s IDF, the Defendants posted the following articles on the H’s hosting room:

(♡, ♥는 성적 표현이나 욕설로서 금칙어에 해당되어 블라인드 처리된 것). 이름 아이디 게시 글 내용 일자 B J “G 빨갱이임 ” “G 종북세력임 ” 2015. 10. 14. C K “비제이 빨갱.이죠” “비제이 빨갱이삘개나는데” 2015. 10. 9. D L “♡련아” “망치로♡깨부셔버린다” “망치로머리부셔버리기전에” “입닥쳐” “시♥발련아” 2015. 10. 8. E M “♡ G ㅈ추천합시다♡야 니네나라로 떠나라 보@지를 찢어불라” 2015. 10. 7. [인정 근거] 피고 B, D, E: 다툼 없는 사실, 갑 1, 3, 6, 7호증(가지번호 포함), 변론 전체의 취지 피고 C : 자백간주

2. Determination

A. In light of the contents of the Plaintiff’s broadcast content, the context and method of expression posted by the Defendants, and the motive of posting the article, etc., it can be deemed that a maliciously slandered or insulting the Plaintiff in a state where many unspecified people view the Plaintiff’s personal broadcasting beyond a legitimate surveillance and criticism on the content of the broadcast. Accordingly, the Plaintiff may be deemed to have abused or insulting the Plaintiff.