1. The following amount among the parts against Defendant Seocho-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government judgment of the first instance.

1. Basic facts

A. The status and related facilities 1) the Myeongsan was located in both Seocho-gu Seoul, Seocho-gu, Seoul, and the Dogsan was located in the area of 293 meters high, and the Dogsan was located in the area of the housing complex, such as the apartment complex of the Seocho-dong, the discharge-dong, and the upper and lower village, adjacent to the south cycle. The Dogsan was located in the area of the residential complex, such as the Seocho-gu, the west-dong, the Dog-dong, the Dog-dong, the Dog-dong, and the Dog-dong, the Dog-dong, the Dog-dong apartment complex and the housing complex are located in the south, and the housing complex and agricultural facilities such as the Dogsan-dong, the Dog-dong, the Dog-dong and the Dog-dong village are located in the area of the Dogsan, and the Dogsan-si and the Dog-dong at the same time.

B. 1) The outbreak of a landslide in the Dogsan City was formed from September 21, 2010 to September 23, 2010 due to the influence of typhoons on the Dogsan City. The landslide (area 4.2 ha, approximately 400,000,000, and below "2010" hereinafter) occurred in the Dogsan City. As a result, the combination of rocks (a relatively high concentration with water), gravel, sand, and soil flow into the new dong apartment in Seocho-gu, Seoul and Seocho-gu. The specific landslide and rock generation from September 21, 201 to September 23, 2010 to 0: 200,000,000 (attached Table 1.2 4 m2 m2 m2 m21 m21 m27 m21 m27 m261 m27 m21 m261 m27 m261 m20.