1. The defendant, Seocho-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government, and the defendant Republic of Korea, of the plaintiff U, V, plaintiff W, and X in the judgment of the first instance.

1. Basic facts

(a) The current status of the Myeonsan mountain is 293 meters high in height located in the same region, such as Yang-dong, Seocho-gu, Seoul, and Do-dong, and from the shore on the north-west mountain zone, the South-west circulation road passes along the eastwest in the direction of the Dong, and the apartment complex of the Do-dong, and the upper and rear village, etc. adjoining the South-west circulation road, are located in the westwest, and a housing complex is located in the westwest, such as the South-west village, the west-west village, the west-west village, the west-west village, and the west village, etc., the apartment complex and the housing complex in the west, both-dong, the west-dong apartment complex and the housing complex in the west, and the rural facilities are located in each area.

B. The basin, such as a new East-dong Dorog apartment (hereinafter “instant new Dong apartment”), a lux apartment, and a Dorotone apartment, which are abutting on the South side cycle of the Dorosan among the Dorosan’s geological characteristics, constitutes “risk” at the risk of soil and stone at the rate of 84% to 87%, and falls under class 2 of the Dorogic geological hazard level of 60 to 60-80, with “seriously unstable” of 60 to 60.

C. The Korea Forest Service established a landslide management system from 2006 and supplied it to each local government.

The landslide management system provides through the website of the Korea Forest Service the map of a landslide risk area indicating the nationwide mountainous district by classifying the nationwide mountainous district according to the risk level in four levels, taking into account slope length, mother rock, slope location, tree type, surface style, earth depth, and gradient, and the area of the new East Asian Apartment and the Dominal Apartment apartment among the Dominsan Pung Pung Pung Pung Pung Pung, etc. is classified as the first-class landslide risk area in the landslide management system from 2006 to 206.

The influence of the typhoons from September 21, 2010 to September 23, 2010 is the phenomenon that the middle chrokes or the soil of the mountain chrokes naturally collapseed from the eurgic acid to the eurgic eurgic eurgic eurgic eurgic eurgic eurgic eurgic eurgic eurgic eurgic eurgics

The landslide in Korea is mainly the rainwater.