1. Defendant Seocho-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government, which exceeds the amount ordered to pay below among the judgment of the first instance.

1. Basic facts

A. Dogsan is a mountain village with a height of 293 meters located in the same region, such as Yang-dong, Seocho-gu, Seoul, and Dogdong, and from the shores of North Korea, the south side is passing along the west cycle to the westwest, and a housing complex is located, such as Seocho-dong, Dog-dong, and Dog-dong, and I village, adjacent to the south side circulation. The west side of the west, a housing complex, such as Jdong, K village, and Dong-dong, the apartment complex and housing complex in the west side, and agricultural facilities are located, respectively. 2) The defendant of Seocho-gu, upon delegation by the defendant Seoul Special Metropolitan City (hereinafter referred to as the "Defendant Seoul Special Metropolitan City"), created a rural park with subsidies from the city expenses of the defendant Seoul Metropolitan City on November 2, 2002 to the west 40 Myeong City (hereinafter referred to as the "Seoul Metropolitan City") on the south side of the west side.

3) The air base managed by the Defendant Republic of Korea is located in the west mountain. 4) The Defendant Seoul Special Metropolitan City started the installation work of a tunnel leading to the north direction from around 2000 to the south of the west mountain, and opened the west mountain tunnel around 2004. From November 5, 2008 to the south side of the west mountain as shown in the Appendix No. 1, 2008.

B. 1) The occurrence of a landslide in the U.S. is the phenomenon that the upper-side stone or soil of the mountain chrospheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spheric spherics

A. The occurrence of a landslide, as shown in the attached Form 2, has occurred, and the earth and rocks flown from two basins of sculke, sculke, and sculical valleys. DebrisFow. A landslide occurring within the mountain basin in the mountain basin.