beta
Text
1. All of the plaintiffs' claims are dismissed.
2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.
Reasons
1. Determination on the cause of the claim
A. 1) Plaintiff A, Defendant E, G and J, K, L, M, N, and other entities P and P and P, Q are the first grade high school students in Q and Q are the first grade students in the S Information Industry, and P and one grade high school students in the first grade students in T and one grade. (2) Defendant E and G are the first grade students in the new wall play in the Seoul Dongjak-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government U.S., and Q and expressed multiple force over Plaintiff A during the course of assaulting Plaintiff A, such as Q and her head at the new wall play in the middle of the Plaintiff’s head knife in the middle of the Plaintiff’s head knife. (2) During the course of assaulting the Plaintiff’s head knife, Q, O, L, and M, the Plaintiff’s face and head knife in the above U.S. parking lot, the Plaintiff was urged to exercise multiple influence over Plaintiff A and U.N. in the neighboring parking lot.
3) As stated in paragraph (2), Plaintiff A suffered serious psychological impulses due to violence from Q, etc., suffering from the diagnosis of external stress disorder due to the post-treatment, and voluntarily leaving the school, etc.
4) Plaintiffs B, C, and D are the parents, advisers, and Defendant F is the parents of Defendant G. Defendant E, Defendant I, and H jointly with Defendant G. Defendant E, and Defendant G assaulted the Plaintiff. Defendant F, I, and H violated their duty to educate minors as the father or mother of Defendant E, G, who is a minor, and thus, they are jointly and severally with Q et al. (Plaintiff A: 5,823,330, 1,397,200, consolation money, KRW 10,00,00, KRW 2,000, KRW 2,000, respectively.
B. As to whether Defendant E and G participated in the Plaintiff’s assault and are liable for joint tort, the following circumstances, namely, Q et al., acknowledged by comprehensively considering the purport of the entire pleadings in each of the statements in the Health Team and evidence Nos. 18 through 25.