1. On October 1, 2014, the Defendant stated each amount in the “personal fee” column in attached Form 5 to the Plaintiffs and each of them.

1. Basic facts

A. The Plaintiffs are street cleaners employed and employed by the Defendant, who belong to the Democratic Labor Union General Workers’ Union (hereinafter “instant union”).

B. On March 17, 2011, the Defendant prepared “the payment criteria for the replacement of street cleaners in 201”; on February 20, 2012, the instant union entered into a collective agreement and wage agreement with the instant union; on August 8, 2013, the instant union entered into a collective agreement or wage agreement with the instant union; on January 8, 2014, the “the payment plan for the personnel expenses of street cleaners in 2014” was prepared; on October 30, 2014, the Defendant prepared the “the payment criteria for the personnel expenses of street cleaners in 2014” (hereinafter “the instant wage payment criteria”), and on October 30, 2014, the “the payment criteria for street cleaners in 2011” and “the payment plan for the personnel expenses of street cleaners in 2014” are as stated in attached Table 1.

C. The defendant paid basic pay, ② bonus [the last day allowance (the last day allowance, June, September, and December 50%), fixed-time allowance (the 50% of January and July), physical training allowance (the 50% of April, May, August, October, October, and December), ③ fixed-amount allowance [family allowance, special work allowance, work encouragement allowance], ④ welfare expenses [the fixed-amount meal allowance, household allowance, traffic allowance, long-term leave allowance (the 60% of each opinion, year, year), and year-time allowance] as set out in the wage payment standard of this case. On the other hand, the defendant calculated only basic pay, special allowance, work encouragement allowance, household meal allowance, day-time allowance, day-time allowance, overtime work allowance (the 3th day of night work, day-time work allowance, day-time work allowance, day-time work allowance of the plaintiffs, day-time work allowance (the 3th day of night work allowance, day-time work allowance, day-time work allowance of the plaintiffs.