1. All of the plaintiffs' claims are dismissed.

2. The costs of the lawsuit, including those resulting from the participation, shall be all included.

1. Details of the decision on retrial;

A. The parties’ status company employees were 103 Taeyang-si Co., Ltd., 112 Taeyang-dong Transport Co., Ltd., 129 Taewon-dong Co., Ltd., 197 Sungdong-dong Co., Ltd., Ltd., 125 Sungdong-dong Co., Ltd.) and the defendant joining the defendant, Daeung-dong Co., Ltd., 197 Woo-dong Co., Ltd., Ltd. (hereinafter collectively referred to as the "participating Co., Ltd.")

The number of workers is as follows. The Plaintiffs are corporations operating the taxi transport business in Busan. The number of the Plaintiffs are as follows. The Plaintiffs are the unit trade unions of the Intervenor companies, the number of which is as follows: 15 members of the Plaintiff-based taxi trade union, the number of members of the Plaintiff-based taxi trade union, the 15 members of the Plaintiff-based taxi trade union, the 2 members of the Taewon-dong Transport Trade Union, the 3 members of the Taewon-dong Transport Trade Union, the 9 members of the Taewon-dong taxi trade union, the Taewon-dong Transport Trade Union, the 9 members of the Sungwon-dong Transport Trade Union, the 9 members of the Sungdong

approximately 100 Taewon Transport Co., Ltd., about 100 Taewon-dong Transport Co., Ltd., Taewon-dong Co., Ltd., about 100 members of the workplace branch, which is about 90 members of the Daeung-si Co., Ltd. and about 180 members of Taewon-dong Transport Association, about 100 members of Taewon-dong Co., Ltd. (100 members of Taedong-dong Military Co., Ltd.), the defendant joining the defendant's defendant's defendant's 180 members of the National

(B) The Intervenor Company is a national industrial trade union established with the organization of employees engaged in the taxi transport business, and has branches of each workplace for the Intervenor Company, and the number of its members is as follows. (B) The Intervenor Company delegated the authority to conclude a collective agreement in 2015 to the Passenger Transport Business Association in Busan Metropolitan City. The Intervenor Company became a representative bargaining trade union in each workplace of the Intervenor Company from January 2015 to March 2015.