1. All appeals filed by the plaintiffs are dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal are assessed against the Plaintiffs.

Purport of claim and appeal

1...

1. The grounds for this part of the court’s liability for damages are as follows: (a) the occurrence of liability for damages is identical to “1. The occurrence of liability for damages” among the grounds of the judgment of the court of first instance; and (b) the same is cited by

2. Except as otherwise stated below within the scope of liability for damages, each corresponding item of the attached Table of Calculation of Compensation Amount.

In principle, the period for the convenience of the calculation shall be calculated on a monthly basis, but the period of less than the last month and less than KRW 1 shall be discarded.

The calculation of the current value at the time of the accident shall be based on the reduction rate of 5/12 percent per month to deduct the interim interest.

Plaintiff

At A’s request, kneea treatment expenses, knee-pane-path and other medical expenses are insufficient to be recognized only by the entries in the evidence No. 8 through 12, and it is not accepted as there is no other evidence to acknowledge it.

In addition, it is rejected that the parties' arguments have not been separately explained.

Personal information 110,423,522 won: 2) Income and operating period are as indicated in the “basic matters” list of the amount of damages calculated: 2) Income and income equivalent to KRW 2,500,000 per month until the age of 60,000, the maximum working age (the Defendant did not report proper income, and the Plaintiff’s income cannot be acknowledged on the ground that he did not hold a certificate of creative subscription; however, in full view of the arguments in the evidence Nos. 7 and 15, it is sufficiently recognized that the Plaintiff obtained income of KRW 2,50,000 per month prior to the instant accident, and thus, the Defendant’s above assertion is not acceptable) income according to the disability and the rate of loss of labor ability due to work disability under the attached table of the amount of damages calculated 3). - Income and operation period is deemed to have been able to obtain income (the Defendant’s assertion that the Plaintiff did not report proper income and that he did not have a certificate of occupational disability 3: the rate of loss and injury 48-1% rate due to the injury.