The defendant shall be innocent.

1. The Defendant is a driving engineer belonging to the C, a member belonging to the E-C branch of the Korea Trade Union's Public Transport Labor Coordination Headquarters E-C branch of the Korea Trade Union, and the victim F is a driver belonging to the said company and the G Trade Union member.

The branch of the Korea Trade Union Group E branch of the Korea Trade Union Group E branch of the Korea Trade Union Group E branch of the Korea Trade Union to which the Defendant belongs was involved in the strike from March 13, 2012, and the said sub-C branch was included in the partial lock-out from March 20, 2012 to the members of the Korea Trade Union.

On April 13, 2012, at around 06:02, the Defendant: (a) entered into the KC company located in Geumcheon-gu Seoul Special Metropolitan City, Seoul Special Metropolitan City on April 13, 2012, entered the course of the victim’s I city bus operation, and obstructed the victim’s bus transport by force, such as the victim’s bus rapid stop, but the victim’s side, such as a part of the bus stoped on the front part of the victim’s bus; (b) the victim was in contact with the bus of the victim, and the victim was in contact with the bus of the victim, and the traffic accident was paid by the victim.

2. Determination

A. According to the evidence adopted and examined by this court, the defendant, at the time of the instant case, stopped the bus driver in front of the bus entering the bus and stopped the bus in front of the bus entering the bus in order to verify whether the replacement manpower has been placed into the bus engineer from the bus entering the bus entrance route of the bus garage at the time of the instant case, and then there was no particular hindrance to the bus transport service due to the bus driver's response to this patrol, and while the defendant stops J urban bus as above and takes a front of the bus, F stops the I urban bus after 2-3 meters of the above bus while driving the bus. The defendant completed photographs before J urban bus leaving the bus in front of the bus and went off the bus entering the bus by leaving the bus open.