1. Each of the plaintiffs' claims is dismissed.

2. The costs of the lawsuit, including those resulting from the participation, shall be all included.

1. Details of the decision on retrial;

A. 1) The intervenor is a legal entity established to provide education, such as elementary, secondary and high schools, according to the attachment of the character church, which is a party to the case.

(2) On March 1, 1986, the Plaintiff A was employed as a nurse of the E Hospital and continued to work at the D Hospital after having been employed by 1,400 full-time workers.

3) On March 9, 1998, the Plaintiff B’s union is a national industrial trade union organized with its employees engaged in the health and medical industry, and as the D Hospital Branch (hereinafter “instant branch”).

From March 1, 200 to December 31, 2003, Plaintiff A served as the head of the instant branch, the vice-chairperson and the leader of the Plaintiff B trade union from January 1, 2004 to May 31, 201, and the head of the instant branch from June 1, 201 to January 7, 2016. (B) The Internet media, which is the Plaintiff’s Internet media operated by the Plaintiff C, Inc., Ltd., for the purpose of “H”, and “a hospital’s staff, etc.,” and “a hospital’s staff member, etc., may frequently assign the number of general patients and the results of health examinations to all its employees,” and “a hospital’s staff member, etc., who is not a member of the instant branch, was informed of the current method of advertising the Plaintiff’s membership at the hospital and the head of the D hospital.”

2. On April 6, 2015, some of the employees of the D Hospital were posted after the publication of the said article.

9. and on the 10th day of the same month, the plaintiff A was searched for.