1. The plaintiff's appeal is dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

Purport of claim and appeal

The first instance court.

1. Basic facts

A. The Plaintiff is a trade union comprised of the employees working at the B Hospital’s workplace, C Hospital’s workplace, and D Hospital’s workplace under A (hereinafter “A”), and Defendant B Hospital’s labor union is a trade union comprised of employees working at the workplace of B Hospital. Defendant C Hospital’s labor union is a trade union consisting of employees working at the workplace of C Hospital, and Defendant C Hospital’s labor union is a trade union consisting of employees working at the workplace of D Hospital.

B. 1) Former A-affiliated B Hospital, C Hospital, E Hospital, and D Hospital were in existence, and on February 27, 2009, the trade unions of B Hospital, C Hospital, and D Hospital except E Hospital were held to make an integrated conference and declared the integration of the trade unions, and made a resolution against F as the chairperson of the integrated promotion council. On October 27, 2009, the said three hospital trade unions held temporary meetings on each of the temporary representatives and adopted a resolution to amend the regulations and rules (the contents that the scope of union members shall be expanded to workers employed in the workplace of the school foundation G), the amendment of the election regulations (the election of the chairperson of the first branch and the head of the branch office due to the integration shall be conducted in the representatives of the schools), and the trade unions of the said three hospitals were incorporated into the said three hospitals (the trade unions of the previous three hospitals after the establishment of the Plaintiff thereafter constituted the type of each of the branch offices of the Plaintiff.

(2) On November 6, 2009, the Plaintiff (i) held a conference to elect officers on November 6, 2009 in accordance with the amended regulations and the election management regulations, and (ii) elected the chairman and the head of each branch in accordance with the integration. (iii) The chairman of the Plaintiff’s representative was elected as the representative of the Plaintiff for about 19 years as the chairman and the full-time officer of the pertinent hospital, and (iv) was elected as prescribed in paragraph (1).