Text
1. The plaintiffs' appeal against the defendant and the defendant's appeal against the plaintiffs are all dismissed.
2. The appeal costs.
Reasons
1. In the instant lawsuit claiming damages from the Defendant by asserting that Plaintiff D was guilty of indecent act against the Defendant on the ground of this safety defense, the Defendant asserted that the lawsuit filed against the above agreement is unlawful, since the Plaintiff and D reached an agreement to bring an action with Plaintiff D to bring an action against the Defendant.
According to the statements in the evidence Nos. 1, 7-1 and 2, it is recognized that Plaintiff D prepared a written pledge to the effect that Plaintiff D would be at issue or would not raise any objection to the Defendant’s indecent act on or around July 20, 2013.
However, according to the evidence mentioned above, since the plaintiff D prepared a written oath as above and did not reach the final agreement with the defendant, it is recognized that the above written pledge was not delivered to the defendant, and thus, it cannot be deemed that the agreement between the plaintiff D and the defendant on the same action as the contents of the above written pledge was concluded.
Therefore, the defendant's main defense is without merit.
2. Determination on the establishment of liability for damages
A. (1) The following facts can be acknowledged in light of the overall purport of the pleadings in each of the evidence Nos. 1 through 4, 6 through 9, and 14.
(A) On February 20, 2013, around 20:00, the Defendant inserted the Plaintiff’s own hand from the behind the Plaintiff’s bridge, a customer, who was up to the second floor of the 2nd floor in Ulsan-gu G, Ulsan-gu G, which was operated by him, and committed an indecent act against Plaintiff A by coercioning the Plaintiff from the Plaintiff’s music to the her her amb, and by forcing the Plaintiff to use her amb from March 14:00 on March 2013, 2013, the Defendant sent the Plaintiff “A ambling ambling. Gabbbbs” to the Plaintiff who was going up from the second floor of the 2nd sports horse room of the 2nd floor of the 2nd group of the 2nd group of the 2nd group of the 2nd group of the 2nd group of the 2013.