1. The plaintiff's appeal is dismissed.

2. The appeal cost (including the part resulting from the supplementary participation) shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. As to the instant case cited in the judgment of the court of first instance, the reasoning of this court is as stated in the reasoning of the judgment of the court of first instance, except for partial revision as follows. Thus, it is acceptable in accordance with Article 8(2) of the Administrative Litigation Act and Article 420 of the Civil Procedure Act.

The attached Form 2 in the attached Form 3 of the judgment of the first instance court shall be sealed as the following, and the following table shall be added between the second and third in the attached Form 1:

The second evaluation of the evaluation unit (marks) of the evaluation field;

1. Contribution to the lectures of education – Evaluation of class 36, such as hours in charge and plans for classes - Evaluation of students' performance of class, methods of class, evaluation of grade, etc. - Examination of students' performance in consideration of the results of class evaluation - Examination of students' interview and instruction, guidance of the club of the ASEAN, degree of doctoral degree for guidance of the club of the ASEAN -

2. Research papers and author - Results of publication of domestic and overseas academic journals - Results of publication of author(s) - Results of publication of author(s) and author(s) - research activities of author(s) and author(s) - amount of benefits from research, research reports - publication and invitation lectures of academic conferences - Patent award(s)

3. Services - Assignment to the Board and activities of committees - Degree of participation in intra-school and extracurricular events, contribution - Service activities related to study officers and academic groups - Consultation activities of governmental agencies and public interest groups - Contribution to the development of the community - Award, decoration and commendation 18.

4. - Compliance with other education-related Acts and subordinate statutes and regulations - personality and dignity as a teacher - personality and dignity within the school department, contribution to the development of the department to which he belongs 10th and 100th and 3th decision of the first instance court on May 11, 2016, “as a result of the examination of whether to re-appoint an intervenor, May 11, 2016” shall be deemed to be “as a result of the examination of the appointment evaluation table for the above former teacher on May 11, 2016, the detailed allocation criteria for each item of assessment shall be determined as shown in attached Table 2, and accordingly, the results of the examination of whether

On the fourth part of the decision of the first instance court, the term "for the reason of speed" in the fourth part of the decision of the first instance is considered to be "for the reason that the binding force needs to be excluded."