1. Defendant A’s imprisonment for three years, Defendant B’s imprisonment for ten months, Defendant C’s imprisonment for two years, and Defendant D.

Punishment of the crime

Defendant

A around April 22, 2005, Hyundai Heavy Industries Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "Y Heavy Industries") serving as the X vice head in the W Headquarters from January 1, 2010 to May 25, 2013, and served as the head of X division (the head of the office division) from May 1, 201 to May 25, 2013. Defendant C served as the head of X division in the Hyundai Heavy Heavy Industries W Headquarters on July 11, 2006 and served as X vice head from July 11, 2008 to April 17, 2013, and Defendant B served as the head of X division in the Hyundai Heavy Heavy Industries from January 1, 2007 to the retirement of the head of the office in charge from January 1, 201 to December 13, 2013 (the head of the office division).

Defendant

A and Defendant C entrusted with affairs related to the Y projects promoted by the Department X of the World Heavy Industries Headquarters X, and took charge of overall affairs related to the Y projects, such as construction contracts, budget compilation, selection of subcontractors, construction supervision, and supervision, and Defendant B took charge of the tasks related to the Y projects. Defendant B took charge of the tasks related to the Y projects, and directed and supervised the tasks related to the Y projects.

On the other hand, Defendant E is a partner of the Hyundai Heavy Industries X division located in Daegu-gu, Daegu-gu, as a construction company for machinery and equipment and fire-fighting equipment and construction company. Defendant D is an electrical construction company, who operates AC (main) as a partner of the Department X division of the Hyundai Heavy Industries X located in Gwangju-si, and AD (former summary indictment on the same day) is a person who operates AF as the ordering agent of the Thailand AE Corporation, the recipient of which entered into a contract for construction in the Hyundai Heavy Industries around March 30, 201, and AG (former summary indictment on the same day) is a person who operates AH in the Gu during the training period of air pollution prevention facilities and water treatment equipment manufacturing business.

1. It is determined that even if most of the relevant criminal facts of Defendant A and B coincide with each other in the corresponding criminal facts of Defendants A and B, the defense of the Defendants is not likely to be infringed.