1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. The following facts may be found either in dispute between the parties or in combination with Gap evidence 2, 4 through 6, 15-1, 18-1, 10-7, and 11-3, and witness evidence D's testimony.

A. (1) On July 28, 2006, the Plaintiff was injured by the left-hand gale gale gale gale that needs to be treated 12 weeks due to the occurrence of the accident where the central separation unit was carried out while driving at the G graduate school located in Mapo-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government and driving at the G graduate school located in Mapo-gu, Seoul Metropolitan Government, and the search station located in the Gayang River. The Plaintiff’s mother-friendly H (1943.) died on the same day due to cerebral wave on the same day.

(hereinafter referred to as the "accident". The first lane in front of the above intersection is the exclusive lane for left-hand and U.S.-on-turned vehicles, and the second lane is the straight-on-only exclusive lane and the two lanes pass through the intersection by the straight-line, the two lanes pass along the intersection by the straight-line one lane, and the center separation zone is set up on the left-hand side of the width.

⑶ 이 사건 사고 직후 원고 운전의 스타렉스는 좌전방부분이 중앙분리대 가드레일의 시작부분과 정면으로 충돌하여 엔진룸 안쪽부분까지 밀려들어가 크게 파손되었고, 그 후미부분이 뒤편에서 진행하던 I 운전의 J 카니발 승합차와 추돌하여 그 아래쪽 부분이 들어 올려진 모양으로 손상된 채 약 10시 30분 방향으로 1차로에서 정지한 상태로, 가드레일 끝부분은 그 충격으로 인하여 사고차량 진행기준 좌측으로 휜 상태로, 카니발은 스타렉스의 후미부분과 조금 떨어져서 그 좌측 모서리부분과 좌측 펜더부분이 손상된 채 진행방향 기준으로 약 12시 30분 방향으로 1차선과 2차선의 경계차선을 걸쳐 정지한 상태로 각 발견되었다.

B. Defendant B’s statement (i.e., the defendants).