1. The part of the judgment of the court of first instance against Plaintiff A, including the claim of Plaintiff A that changed from the trial court, is as follows.

Basic Facts

The pertinent Defendant initially sought joint tort liability against C and the Defendant at the first instance trial co-defendant C (hereinafter “C”) and partly accepted the Plaintiffs’ respective claims on the ground that the first instance court jointly assumed liability for damages against C and the Defendant.

Both Plaintiffs and C appealed to the part on the judgment of the court of first instance, but the decision in lieu of mediation between Plaintiffs and C was finalized on February 3, 2017, which became final and conclusive on the 28th of the same month.

It is a doctor who has worked as the director of the department of anesthesia in Seongbuk-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government E-Ma (hereinafter referred to as "Defendant hospital").

Plaintiff

A on October 2, 2010, is a person who received flaging surgery at the Defendant Hospital, and the Plaintiff B is the husband of the Plaintiff.

On September 16, 2010, Plaintiff A et al. indicated that Plaintiff A’s award date of Plaintiff A and Defendant hospital’s medical records “ September 14, 2010,” but Plaintiff B stated that “A” was “as of September 16, 2010, when the complainant of relevant criminal case was stated.” However, Plaintiff B stated that “A” was “as of September 16, 2010, when the complainant of relevant criminal case was stated.”

(B) (No. 1) A. A. A. A while a community bus was on board, the bus knee-knee-knee-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kne-kn

Plaintiff

A was hospitalized in the Defendant Hospital on the same day and continued to perform the medication and physical therapy of the above symptoms, but it was not protected, and it was expected to undergo the surgery of anti-viral blocking.

On October 2, 2010, the Defendant, including the implementation of the instant medical procedure and the occurrence of an emergency, is a radiation company L and nurse M in the second floor of the Defendant hospital at around 11:25, 2010. Under the aid of the radiation company L and nurse M, the Defendant confirmed that, while pressureing the air in an infecter, the air was spreaded to a tent, and then the Plaintiff’s cliffa (Mpivacine), which is a national anesthesia substance at the outer bottom of the climatic 5th clifa (Ropivacine), the smed.