1. The Defendants jointly and severally against the Plaintiff A, KRW 90,00,000, KRW 75,000,000 for the Plaintiff B, and KRW 80,965,00 for the Plaintiff C, respectively.

1. In a civil trial on the grounds of a claim, even if it is not bound by the finding of facts in a criminal trial, the facts established in a criminal trial on the same factual basis shall be a flexible evidence. Thus, it shall not be recognized that the facts opposed to the finding of facts in a criminal trial cannot be admitted unless there are special circumstances where it is difficult to adopt a factual judgment in light of other evidence submitted in the civil trial.

(1) According to the overall purport of the arguments and arguments, the defendants conspired to acquire the cargo from the transfer of Hanjin Shipping Co., Ltd. and to acquire the money for the purpose of purchasing the cargo from the transfer of Hanjin Shipping Co., Ltd., with the intention of purchasing the cargo for the purpose of purchasing the cargo, the defendant K posted the advertisement for the use of the cargo, explain the contents of the business to the users, Defendant I concluded with the Korean District Court, Defendant J Co., Ltd., Defendant J Co., Ltd., Defendant J Co., Ltd., Defendant J Co., Ltd., and Defendant J Co., Ltd. received the money for purchasing the cargo from the victims, etc., Defendant J Co., Ltd., Defendant J Co., Ltd., and Defendant J Co., Ltd., Defendant J Co., Ltd., Defendant J Co., Ltd., and Defendant J Co., Ltd., Defendant Co., Ltd., Defendant J. 1 and 2 did not receive the money for the purchase of the cargo from the victims to the 10th day of 16th day of 20th day of appeal.