1. Of the judgment of the first instance court, the part of the Plaintiff D’s claim for the revocation of the order or disposition of the subsidy refund order as of July 8, 2014, is revoked, and thus,.

1. Details of the disposition;

A. The status of the Plaintiff, etc. 1) Plaintiff A, B, C, F, and net H (Death on February 3, 201), and I are those engaged in crop cultivation in the Mineyang-si, Plaintiff D’s spouse, Plaintiff E’s spouse, and Plaintiff E’s spouse. 2) On December 222, 2008, the joint Plaintiff G farming association corporation in the first instance trial (hereinafter “foreign corporation”) was established for the purpose of production, processing, sale, and export, etc. of Pakistan, and Plaintiff A, B, and C was appointed as a director at the time of the incorporation of the non-party corporation, and Plaintiff H was appointed as an auditor.

B. The Defendant’s implementation of the Defendant’s subsidized project 1) from 2009 to 2012, 40% of the project cost for the project for the development of the Pakistan farming complex and the project for the installation of the steel-refined vinyl greenhouse was carried out as a subsidy for the remaining 60% of the project cost on the condition that the selected business operator would bear the remainder of 60% of the project cost. 2) The Non-Party Corporation applied for the grant of subsidies for the same subsidized project as indicated below to the Defendant in 2009 and 2010 in the name of Plaintiff E, and Plaintiff F in 2012, respectively. Accordingly, the Defendant decided to grant subsidies and granted subsidies as listed below [Attachment 1].

(1) The subsidy granted for each of the projects in this case shall be specified as follows: (a) the subsidy granted for each of the projects in this case shall be referred to as the "each of the projects in this case"; and (b) the subsidy granted for each of the projects in this case shall be specified by the sequence 1 [Attachment 1] to the "project" or "Project"; and (c) the subsidy granted for each of the projects in this case shall be specified by the table 1 [Attachment 1] to the "Project Subsidy" or the "Project Subsidy" [Attachment 1] [Attachment 1] [Attachment 1] to the subsidy granted for each of the projects in this case. The subsidy granted for each of the projects in this case shall be indicated as the "Project Subsidy" or the "Project Subsidy" [Attachment 1] [Attachment 1] to the subsidy granted for each of the projects in this case. The subsidy granted for each of the projects in the name of the project operator in this case to the Do, non-party to the project for the development of the Do, non-party to the project for the 40000.