1. Revocation of the first instance judgment.

2. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

3. The total cost of the lawsuit is resulting from the supplementary participation.

The Intervenor (English name: D, abbreviated name E) is a non-profit corporation that runs G development projects, etc. using six full-time workers at the Busan Metropolitan City Council (hereinafter referred to as the “Secretariat”) and has been established in the Republic of Korea on August 31, 2002 and consisting of 10 cities and 72 cities in the Republic of Korea.

The intervenor enacted the Administrative Rules of the Secretariat (hereinafter referred to as the "Operation Rules") for the operation of the Secretariat.

On February 15, 2009, the Plaintiff joined the office as a professional P3 position, and served as a deputy secretary-general from March 1, 2012.

The meeting of the 23th Steering Committee of the Intervenor (hereinafter “instant meeting”) was held on September 6, 2013 at Daejeon.

The Deputy Director H, who is the chairperson of the operation committee, has been conducting the meeting of this case, and the Secretary-General, who is the person in charge of the secretariat, has been assisting the chairperson of the operation committee.

The meeting of this case was held by the head of the Busan Metropolitan City bureau and the head of the Daejeon Metropolitan City division, who is an operating member, and the plaintiff, Busan Metropolitan City and Daejeon Metropolitan City public officials, who are not operating members, etc.

However, during the instant meeting, the Plaintiff made a statement without obtaining permission from the Chairperson, and the Secretary General prevented the Plaintiff from speaking on the grounds that the Plaintiff is not an operating member, and the details of the conversation are as follows.

Plaintiff

It is also important that the Secretariat will continue to prepare measures so that the interpreters can participate in (before interpretation is made by an interpreter after the statement of the director general of Busan Metropolitan City).

Secretary General: Huh's Directory General of the Huh's Office: the Director General of the World Trade Organization of Busan Metropolitan City, who is member of the Because mitte (art.) of the Busan Metropolitan City: the proposal that the submission is made now, and the submission of the opinion is made as soon as possible, and the Plaintiff: