1. All appeals by the plaintiffs and the defendant are dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal shall be borne by each party.

purport, purport, and.

1. Basic facts

A. G’s entry and settlement are Chinese nationals residing in the area north of the Military Demarcation Line (hereinafter “North Korea”); around April 25, 2004, North Korean defectors entered the Republic of Korea and settled in the Republic of Korea upon receipt of a decision of protection under the Act on the Protection and Settlement of North Korean Refugees (hereinafter “North Korean Refugees Act”); and from June 9, 201, those who were in office as a contracting officer of the J Team in the Seoul Metropolitan Government Office.

B. H’s entry into the Republic of Korea and the accommodation of the Central Joint Examination Center in North Korea as G’s colon are also born in North Korea. Around October 30, 2012, the Republic of Korea entered the Republic of Korea and applied for protection under the North Korean Refugees Act. Around that time, the head of the NIS was admitted to the Central Joint Examination Center (the name of the North Korean refugee protection center was changed to that of the North Korean refugee protection center around July 28, 2014) that is a temporary protective facility established and operated by the head of the NIS based on the North Korean Refugees Act.

C. (1) around February 201, the NIS made a statement to the effect that she would have entered the Republic of Korea by pretending that she would have entered the Republic of Korea, even though she was in ties from other North Korean defectors, and that she would immediately enter the Republic of Korea. (2) H denied the fact that she was in ties during the initial period of confinement in the course of investigating the developments of entry, etc. from other North Korean investigators. On November 5, 2012, 2012, the NIS acknowledged that she was a Chinese national and did not have acquired North Korean nationality.

3. Since then, the National Intelligence Service shall have H prepare a statement or written confirmation several times, and conduct an investigation of witnesses at least four times, etc., by which H transferred information, etc. on the identity of the North Korean defectors collected from the North Korean residents in North Korea during his/her residence in North Korea, and deliver it to the North Korean Hah-do Hah-do Hah-do Hah-do Hah, and according to the direction of K, the National Intelligence Service collected information about North Korean defectors with G and deliver it to North Korea.