1. The defendant's appeal is dismissed.

2. As to the case of application for the suspension of compulsory execution No. 2016 Chicago195, the Court shall decide on March 2016.

1. Each of the facts under the basis of facts below shall be admitted, either in dispute between the parties or in the entry of Gap evidence 1, 4, 9, 3, and 4 (including serial numbers), with a comprehensive consideration of the whole purport of the pleadings.

A. The relationship between the parties 1) The Southern-ro Market in Seoul Jung-gu 4-gil 21 and South Seodaemun-ro (hereinafter “Seoul-gu Market”)

(C) building Jung-gu Seoul Jung-gu, Seoul (hereinafter referred to as “instant building”)

A) Each floor has a merchants' association composed of merchants of the pertinent floor, and the Plaintiff is a shop in the first floor among the instant buildings (hereinafter referred to as "instant commercial building").

)a merchants' association consisting of 147 merchants of 147 stores operating in the business (hereinafter referred to as "Plaintiff" or "Plaintiff merchants' association"), as the context requires;

On the other hand, D is an organization composed of the props of the building of this case) The defendant is a person operating 140 stores located in the commercial building of this case.

B. The main contents of the rules of the Plaintiff Merchant Association (hereinafter “instant rules”) are as follows.

Article 3 [Purpose] The purpose of this Council is to actively respond to national policies, to promote friendship and unity among members, to work in various irregularitiess in commercial buildings, to promote the friendship and unity of members, to establish a fair and orderly climate of commercial transactions, and to contribute actively to the development of local communities as well as the sound development of simultaneous commercial buildings.

Article 5 [1] [2] The direction of an administrative office 2] The 3) The 5) The proper price indication and implementation of quality labelling system among members, 4) the cost of commercial buildings, fire prevention, sanitation, US dollars, etc. 6) the duties of promoting customer inducement projects 7) the members and employees 8) the culture education, 9) the 10) other duties concerning the development of commercial buildings / [6] the qualification] the members of this administrative office / [3) the members of this association within the jurisdiction of this association.