Defendants are not guilty.

1. The facts charged against Defendant A is the person operating the G sing clubs in the “G sing clubs” in the “F of Chungcheongnam-gun, Chungcheongnam-gun, and Defendant B, C, and Victim H(40 years of age) with the workplace rent.

At around 21:05 on November 28, 2010, Defendant B, C, and the victim, who had been a customer, had been challenged with female employees present at the meeting. The above B, C, and the victim attempted to go out of the meeting without paying the drinking value.

The hallways are narrow and narrow, and the studs are at the entrance of studs, and the studs are at the entrance of the studs, so accidents may occur due to a stude in the studs, door sphers, etc. in cases where the other party to the studs, etc. occurs. Therefore, the above studs are not fighting in the studs or the other party is not required to do so.

Nevertheless, by neglecting this, the payment of the drinking value, Defendant A had been in dispute with the victim, and Defendant B and C had sprinked with the spather with one another, and Defendant B and C had the above victim faced with the door spats on the 3rd entrance of the singing club by negligence after Defendant A. Accordingly, the Defendants came to go beyond the upper part of the victim.

As a result, the Defendants jointly caused the victim, who was missing of consciousness due to the above accident, to die in the pansty in the patient room at the J Hospital in Seogsan-si around November 30, 2010.

2. Defendants’ assertion

A. Defendant A (1) although the above Defendant was less than 1’s bomb, it was less than 1’s bomb, and the upper Defendant B and C was pushed down in Defendant A’s rear. Thus, Defendant A and C came to go beyond the bomb.

(2) Even if the Defendant was pushed the victim, it was not foreseeable that the victim would die, and there was no causal relationship.

B. Defendant B.