1. All of the plaintiffs' claims are dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.

1. Basic facts

A. The plaintiffs were NN who joined and joined the Kafa in this case where those who hold NN qualification licenses can join the Kafa through certification procedures, and the defendant is the operator who operates the Kafa (Kafa).

B. The instant car page is an Internet car page established on the Internet portal siteO (P) operated by the O Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “O”).

R using the undisclosed Q “S” was established around October 25, 2003 under the name of “S,” and around June 2, 2008, the name of the said car page was changed to “T” and operated.

The Defendant used the “U” from the time of the establishment of the instant car page and operated the said car page by taking over the operator’s status from Q around December 5, 2008.

C. N wishing to subscribe to the instant car page may subscribe to the said car page by sending a certified document, such as N license, to the operator of the said car page as a e-mail, and then by linking the car page sent by e-mail.

The above e-mail states that “the instant car page is an anonymous car page, and thus, it may be forced to withdraw if the car page is leaked to the outside or if the car page is lent to the outside. It should not speak or take a bath, or if many members are disadvantaged, it must consent to the rules, such as following the management of the bulletin board of the operator, and may be forced to withdraw if it is violated.” It is deemed that responding to the first car page is consented to the above rules.”

If a associate member (quasi-member) rating is granted to a member who has joined the instant car page, and if a letter certifying N is registered with the former member, a regular member (general member) rating shall be granted, and a member with at least a regular member (general member) rating may prepare or read a letter on the bulletin board.

The operating rules publicly announced in the car page of this case are intended for other members within the car page.