Text
1. The Plaintiff’s appeal against Defendant B and D and the appeal against Defendant C by Defendant C are all dismissed.
2...
Reasons
1. Basic facts
A. Party 1) The Plaintiff is a land-based factory E and seven lots of land (hereinafter “Plaintiff factory”).
2) The Defendant C is a company operating the pel-line manufacturing business, etc., and Defendant C is the Defendant C’s above-ground factory (hereinafter “Defendant C factory”) located between the Plaintiff’s factory and the Plaintiff’s secondary road.
(2) Defendant B is the husband of G, who is the representative director of Defendant C, and Defendant D is the company engaged in the business of manufacturing styp pumps, etc. like Defendant C, and the representative director is the defendant B.
B. (1) On May 21, 2013, Defendant C contracted to H an appurtenant work, etc. of Defendant C’s factory building room (construction works in the building room of factory, construction works in the second floor of commercial building, construction works in the width of the second floor of commercial building, and construction works between the second floor of commercial building and the factory building) in the amount of KRW 35 million. 2) On June 9, 2013, Defendant C performed a melting work in accordance with the said contract, around 13:30, 2013, covering concrete into the passage connected to the commercial building with the second floor of Defendant C’s manufacturing Dong building and warehouse.
3) On the right side of the place where H performed the melting work as above, a large number of 2m in length and 4m in height in the Defendant C factory were loaded. However, the fire that occurred during the melting work, while being loaded at approximately 1m away from the site of the work, was destroyed by a fire that was loaded at approximately 1m away from the site of the work, and as seen above, the fire that occurred at Defendant C factory was moved to the Plaintiff factory located on the second line road along the wind, and the machinery, equipment, and the products produced by the Plaintiff, etc. in the Plaintiff factory and the Plaintiff factory were transferred (hereinafter “instant fire accident”).
A. The occurrence occurred.
C. The plaintiff's fire insurance money.