1. Of the instant lawsuit, C’s vicarious exercise of claim for damages is dismissed.

2. The plaintiff's remainder.

1. Facts of recognition;

A. 1) The D Group was changed from May 31, 201 to E by C Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “C”) that is a domestic company.

hereinafter referred to as “C”

(2) The name of the company that omitted the corporation, the plaintiff, and the F Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the "stock

(2) A business group consisting of 10 companies, including G, H, I, J, K, L, and Japan, and N companies of Singapore, as the president of the D group, have overall control over the overall management of its affiliate companies. (2) The Plaintiff is a company affiliated to the D group, which is engaged in manufacturing of steel vehicles, manufacturing of machinery, assembling of equipment, writing materials for shipbuilding and manufacturing of industrial machinery, and C is a company affiliated to the D group, which is engaged in the construction and sale of vessels, remodeling of vessels, repair of vessels, and repair business.

3) The Intervenor joining the Defendant (hereinafter “Korea Development Bank”)

(2) On December 8, 2009, the Korea Development Bank applied for “corporate improvement work” to the Korea Development Bank on the following grounds: (a) the Korea Development Bank was established to develop and foster industry, expand social infrastructure, develop regional development, stabilize financial markets, and promote sustainable growth; (b) the Defendant was the head of the Korea Development Bank’s corporate restructuring team. (c) On December 8, 2009, the Korea Development Bank filed an application for “corporate improvement work” with the Korea Development Bank; and (d) the Korea Development Bank was accompanied by the plan for business normalization on the grounds that “O and C, which have been in charge of overall business management of its affiliates as the chairperson of the shipbuilding industry due to global financial crisis, cancellation of contracts due to the delay in delivery of vessels, increase in the cost of shipbuilding, raising the cost of shipbuilding, and raising funds for the representative director P at the time of the relevant type C and C, who have been in charge of overall business normalization.

2. Korea Development Bank's internal credit risk assessment results with respect to C on December 17, 2009 to "an enterprise that constitutes an enterprise showing signs of insolvency and is likely to normalize its business", and theO and C on December 17, 2009 to "an enterprise that constitutes an enterprise showing signs of insolvency and is likely to normalize its business."