1. The plaintiff's appeal is dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

Purport of claim and appeal

Judgment of the first instance.

1. Basic facts

A. The defendant is a legal entity that establishes and operates a mutual membership golf course of “F” (hereinafter “instant golf course”) at the time of Kimhae-si, Kim Il-si, and the plaintiff is a VIP member of the said golf course.

(b) 2 full-time members registered with 100% prior to the special benefits of only the FVIP members who subscribe to VIP membership and enter into membership agreements, and 3 full-time member card holders with 4 regular member cards prior to the issuance of 100% prior to the special benefits of the FVIP membership and 10% prior to the end of each week and 2 members with 5 family members prior to the special treatment of 5 regular member with 4 regular member card holders prior to the exemption of the Green Credit Card (the exemption of green fee and the treatment of 10-day associate members from the reservation of the week), 7 full-time members prior to the 6-day special registration (the treatment of 10-day associate members from the reservation of the week), 70-day member with 0-day special benefits of 50-day member with 0-day basic interest of 50-day member with 0-day basic interest of 50-day member with 0-day basic interest of 50-day member with 0-day basic interest.

1) From April 2007, the Defendant recruited 35 VIP members of the instant golf course from around 900,000 to KRW 00,000. At the time, the Defendant advertised that a certain amount of benefits was given to VIP members (Evidence 2). The main contents of the advertisement are as follows (Evidence 2) on June 14, 2007 between the Defendant and the Defendant, setting the membership fee of KRW 900,00,000 with respect to one unit of VIP membership in the instant golf course (hereinafter “instant membership agreement”), and the said membership agreement was concluded.