1. All of the plaintiffs' claims are dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.

1. Basic facts

A. In the case of the sacrifice of civilians in the ancient Chang-gu area, the military police squad consisting of the 6th class of the 20th class of the 11th group, 6th class of the 20th class of the 11 group, the 8th class of the 8th class, the former North Korean police, and the senior police, etc., who belong to the defendant of the 11th class of the 1950 group, was in progress from November 1950 to May 1951.

In the process, the majority of the civilians in the above regions were killed by police and military personnel without due process due process due to salutism, rapid salutism, salutism, etc.

(hereinafter referred to as “the civilian sacrifice case in the ancient area”). (b)

1) The Framework Act on the Settlement of History for Truth and Reconciliation (hereinafter “The Act on the Settlement of History”) is the Act on the Settlement of History for Truth and Reconciliation.

(1) The Committee on the Settlement of History for the Truth and Reconciliation established pursuant to the Act (hereinafter referred to as the “Committee on Settlement of History”) shall be deemed to be the Committee.

(2) On December 1, 2005, from around November 30, 2006 to around November 30, 2006, the Commission rendered a decision to the effect that “The murdering of an armed civilian who was employed by the National Armed Forces and the police in their occupation without lawful procedures in the ancient area is against the humanitarianism, and is against the right to life, due process and the right to trial, which are fundamental rights of the people guaranteed by the Constitution, should be infringed on” (see, e.g., Supreme Court Decision 2006Da1548, Jun. 30, 201).

3 At the time of the above decision, in the course of the implementation of Q uniform operations in order to recover the whole of North Chang-gun P on December 28, 1950, "R S" was judged to have been killed in the field of the village back of the village by putting it into U, V, W, etc. in the ancient Chang-gun T Village of North Chang-gun, Chang Chang-gun, North Korea along with U, V, W, etc., and "RX" is the victim of the civilian sacrifice in the Go Chang-si area.