1. The Defendants are jointly and severally and severally liable to the Intervenor succeeding to the Plaintiff for KRW 60,435,505 and the aforementioned amount from April 14, 2017 to December 13, 2017.

1. Basic facts

A. Defendant B (C), the Plaintiff (C) and E (C) are children of the network FG couple, and Defendant C and D are children of Defendant B.

H is the Plaintiff’s wife.

B. The Plaintiff and the Defendant previously owned part of F-owned shares of 1,000 square meters in I,00.3 square meters in Seongdong-gu Seoul, Seoul, and the relevant above-ground housing (hereinafter “1 land”), and JJ 329.5 square meters in part, and the above-ground housing (hereinafter “land 2,” “building 2,” and “when all of the real estate are distributed, sold, donated, etc.” (hereinafter “the instant real estate”).

At present, specific shares in the real estate of this case are as follows.

The shares whose registration of inheritance has not yet been completed after G death shall be treated as inheritance inherited by the plaintiff, E, and defendant B in 1/3.

Real estate H A is a clan, the representative of which is Plaintiff B, Defendant C, D E, the representative of which.

In addition, the family members of the plaintiff and the defendant own the part of the building sites of Nos. 1 and 2 of the land No. 1 and 2, and maintain the co-ownership relationship with the other co-owners of the land No. 1 and 2 with each

Land 1 77.45 398 25 589.725 583 725 583.725 259.15 2861.2/12,990 2 land 777.45 583.725 583.725 259.15 398 2861.2/12,990 1, 22/12/12 3/123/12 2/121

C. From December 5, 2000, the Defendants, while managing the instant real estate from around December 5, 200, transferred Plaintiff 37.5% and H’s claims against the Defendants regarding the instant real estate to the Plaintiff in consideration of the above equity ratio, etc.

The Defendants paid the settlement amount to the Plaintiff in accordance with the agreement between the original Defendants and E (hereinafter “instant agreement”) to distribute the ratio of 50.3% and E 1.86%.

On July 7, 2017, in order to collect a total of 391,967,780 won from the Plaintiff’s tax claims against the Plaintiff, the succeeding intervenor seized the Plaintiff’s claim of this case against the Defendants under the National Tax Collection Act. On July 10, 2017, the aforementioned attachment notice was given to the Defendants.