1. Defendant (Appointed Party) and Appointed C jointly share KRW 24,706,300 with respect to the Plaintiff and the Plaintiff from October 31, 2015.

1. Basic facts

A. The Plaintiff is an individual entrepreneur who mainly produces and processes sludge with the trade name of “E,” and the Selection C is an individual entrepreneur who acts as a broker for the products with the trade name of “F,” and Defendant B is a person who acts as a broker for the uniforms using the trade name of “F,” as Defendant C.

Defendant D uses office, telephone, facsimile, etc. operated by Defendant C in the trade name of “G” as it is, and engages in brokerage transactions of uniforms.

B. Around September 2014, the Defendant (Appointed Party; hereinafter “Defendant”) sought the Plaintiff and proposed that “The Defendant is engaged in the business with the appointed Party C. As the Plaintiff supplied the uniforms to the transaction parties, such as the KCAB and the Seoul Jung-gu Office, it would create a change in the uniforms. The settlement terms would include the delivery of the products, and then make settlement (including additional tax) in cash.” The Plaintiff accepted this and made a transaction (hereinafter “instant transaction”).

The Plaintiff created and supplied most of the products as listed below in the order of the Defendant and the designated parties C between September 2014 and May 2015, and the outstanding amount was too much, and no delivery was made for some products.

(Unsupplyd goods shall be the total of 1,785,00 won Nos. 8,340,000 and 41-1,785,000 of the following table Nos. 38.38. 50, 200 80,400 2,4000 8030,4000 290 80302,7600 3906 3915 3915 7630,280,000 25,205 205 25,004 204 60,605 206 39,605 204 60,605 204 16,605 205 16,004 25,004 20