1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. Details of the disposition;

A. From around 2009 to 2020, when the Energy Management Corporation establishes new and renewable energy sources, such as solar energy, solar energy, solar energy, geothermal, wind power, and fuel cell, with B’s goal, it has promoted a “B business” (the change of the name to “C business”) as a subsidy support project by the State. On July 29, 2015, the name was changed to the Korea Energy Corporation. (2) The Defendant was established as an affiliated organization of the Energy Management Corporation for the purpose of providing support and management to the executor of the use and distribution business of new and renewable energy. (3) The Defendant annually, based on the construction performance, corporate credit rating, technical personnel holding status, post-management ability, etc. of the installation of new and renewable energy facilities, based on the construction performance, corporate credit rating, and the construction performance of the new and renewable energy facilities installation license, and then, the “public enterprise” selected the “participating public enterprise eligible for participation in the B business, and concluded a contract with the owner of the housing construction and the payment of the subsidy.

3) On January 28, 1999, the Plaintiff was established with the business objective of manufacturing, selling, and constructing solar energy-saving machinery and tools and energy-saving machinery, and from 2012 to 2013, the Plaintiff was “participating public corporation” in relation to the heating construction of the “B business”. At that time, D was the Plaintiff’s internal director. (b) At that time, D’s representative was the Plaintiff’s receipt of subsidies through unlawful means and the progress of the relevant criminal case. (b) The fact that D was the Plaintiff’s representative was the E/F (hereinafter “E, etc.”) that was an unqualified company that is not eligible for the Plaintiff’s participation in the “B business” and the application for subsidies was executed by concluding a contract to install new and renewable energy facilities with the housing owner, such as underground heat, and even if the Plaintiff did not have concluded and executed the contract, the Plaintiff was at all, KRW 3 million per household, etc.