204Heo8732 Nullification of Registration (specific)

Pakistan Co., Ltd.

The additional Dong 60 - 29

The representative director Lee Jae-chul

1. Law Firm continental shelf

Attorney Cho Jong-chul, Kim Jin, Kim Jong-dong, and Kim Il-young

2. Attorney-at-law in the order of business ethics, name of attorney, maximum punishment, and maximum contribution;

Patent Attorney Kim Chang-chul, Jeon Chang-chul, Park Chang-chul, Shin Dong-dong, Song Jin-jin

Barp, Ink (Fore, Dominant Industries)

United States of California 94550 Libera dr. dr. 2140

Representative Scade L. Mercadeo

Attorney Choi Young-young, Yang Young-young, Korea's day, White, Cho Jong-kak, Park Yong-kak, Counsel for the defendant-appellant

Patent Attorney Cho Jae-ho, Sung-dong, Ansan-ho, Park Jong-ho, Kim Sung-ho, leap

Patent attorneys' dives, Nowon-guing

September 15, 2005

October 27, 2005

1. The part of the patent claim No. 31, 35, 39, 43, 70, 72, 73, 72, 82 and 84 of the Patent Tribunal's decision on November 30, 2004 concerning the case No. 584 is revoked.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the defendant.

The order is as set forth in the text.

1. Details of the instant trial decision

A. The defendant is the right holder of the invention of this case as follows.

(1) Name: Search card assembly.

(2) Date of registration / Number of registration: September 9, 2003 / No. 399210

(3) Date/application number of the application: No. 2000/200 - 7003257 (Divisional application No. 1997- 700847) (Priority claim: Nov. 15, 1994; No. 08/34014 and six cases of the United States, Nov. 15, 1994; international application: PC/US 1995/1444 November 13, 1995)

(4) Claims: Attached Form 1.

B. On March 19, 2004, the Plaintiff filed a petition for a trial on invalidation of a patent with the purport that the Defendant’s invention as to “the assembly of the search card on March 19, 2004” did not have industrial applicability, and the detailed explanation and claims are not indicated, and the registration should be invalidated in light of the comparable inventions, and the Patent Tribunal has tried the instant case as 204Da584, Nov. 30, 2004.

The subject of the patent of this case cannot be deemed to fall under an industrial-use invention under the main sentence of Article 29(1) of the Patent Act. The detailed description of the invention of this case and the scope of the claim of this case cannot be deemed to be inconsistent with the provisions of Article 42(3) and (4) of the Patent Act. The claim of this case is not identical to the cited invention 1 through 6 (the cited invention 5 and the cited invention 10,000 and the remainder are different) submitted by the plaintiff to the Intellectual Property Tribunal, and it is not identical to the cited invention 1 through 6 (the cited invention 10,000 and the cited invention 2.), and it is recognized that the complexity of composition, specificity of purpose, and effect of the cited invention is recognized, and it cannot be said that a person with ordinary knowledge in the field of the pertinent technology can easily make an invention, and thus, it cannot be deemed that the plaintiff's claim of this case violates the provisions of Article 29(1

[Evidence] Evidence Nos. 1 and 2, Evidence Nos. 3-1 and 2-2, the purport of the whole pleadings

2. Summary of the grounds for revocation of the Plaintiff’s trial decision

The claim(s) of the instant invention(s) Nos. 31, 35, 39, 43, 70, 72, 73, 82, and 84 of the patent application(s) of the instant invention(s) shall be invalidated since all of the technical compositions as indicated in attached Table 2, publicly notified prior to the application of the instant invention, are the same as, or can be easily claimed from, the other inventions as described in attached Table 2, and thus, the registration of each of the instant inventions shall be revoked. Accordingly, the part on each of the instant patent applications in the instant trial decision should be revoked.

3. Determination on the legitimacy of the instant trial decision

A. Summary of the instant invention

In full view of the purport of the argument in Gap evidence 1, each invention of this case is related to the technology that changes the course of exploration (e.g., tamping direction) to inspect whether semiconductor devices are inferior to semiconductor devices generated in the manufacturing process before individualization by cutting semiconductor devices (Death) from semiconductor wafers. It includes the number of tamples extended from the surface of the search card to tamper as tamper, and it is ordinarily known that multiple tamples ordinarily are extended from the outside part of the search card to search for semiconductor devices, and thus, it is inconsistent with the objective of semiconductors such as the extension of semiconductors to the outside part of the search card to search for other semiconductor devices, and if each semiconductor is difficult to search for other semiconductor devices, it is also difficult for each of such semiconductor to search for the same type of semiconductor devices.

B. Criteria for determining the originality and inventive step of an invention

In principle, the scope or scope of a patent right subject to determination as to whether an invention has a newness or inventive step shall be determined based on the matters described in the claims of the specification attached to the patent application. However, in a case where the technical composition of the patent is unknown or it is impossible to determine the technical scope even if the description is known, the supplement may be made by means of other descriptions in the specification. In this case, even in a case where an extension of the scope of a patent is not allowed by other descriptions in the specification, and where the technical scope is apparent only by the description in the specification, the limitation on the description in the name cannot be interpreted by other descriptions in the specification (Supreme Court Decision 1

5. 28. See Supreme Court Decision 96Hu1118 delivered on April 28, 200

C. Whether the non-obviousness of the instant Claim 35 invention is recognized compared to the comparable inventions (1) technology and preparation for the purpose of the technical field and purpose

The purpose of the instant Claim 35 is to conduct accurate search and inspection by providing Spanish franchises between the search card and semiconductor devices to coordinate the fluorization of Spanish franchises. The purpose of the instant Claim 35 is to conduct reliable pressure connection between the combined fluor corresponding to semiconductor multiples. Invention 1 is to conduct accurate search and inspection by using a reliable pressure connection between the search elements and semiconductors. The purpose of the instant Claim 35 is to examine semiconductor devices in the form of a wafer, a group of members, probra card (Mtebra), a group of members to inspect semiconductor devices in the form of a wafer. However, according to the entire content, the objective of the instant Claim 35 is not clearly stated. The objective of the Prosecutor’s semiconductor is to secure the reputation of semiconductors in semiconductors and semiconductors, and to secure the credibility and semiconductors of semiconductors, regardless of the objective of semiconductors’ electrical contact with semiconductors and semiconductors, and the objective of the Prosecutor’s semiconductor 2 is to secure the reliability of semiconductors and semiconductors.

The contents of the specification are as follows: (a) by the crime group posted on the plate, contact with the chips package; (b) according to the entire specification, it can be known that it contains technology that can accurately contact the chips with the chips and test better electrical characteristics by adjusting the transparency plate attached to the chips by flat coordination use, which is prepared on the card board, in a flat shape; and (c) comparable invention 4 is related to the assembly of semiconductor integrated circuits; (d) the explicit purpose of which is to facilitate contact with the chips’ high density of the chips (p, pin), high density of the chips; (d) the chips’ inside the chip, and (e) the semiconductor invention of this case is to facilitate contact with the chips’s 3rd or chips’ chips’ chips’ chips’ chips’ chips’ chips’ chips’ chip analysis to the same semiconductor of semiconductors’ chip or chip’s chips’s chip analysiss 1 through 3 or chip.

In this regard, the defendant is classified as a member pool, Rim 2, and spawn spawn spawn spawn spawn spawn spawn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn swn.

The claim 35 invention of this case is the invention described in the dependent claim citing paragraph 31 of this case, which is the component of the claim 1, (A), (2), and (1), (b) 1, 2, 2, and 4, adjacent to the multiple contact points placed on the face 1 and extended from the first page, and is connected to the multiple contact points located on the face 1, and (c) 4, adjacent to the search means of the search card (hereinafter referred to as 3), multiple contact points are connected to the multiple contact points of the search card (hereinafter referred to as 4).

(A) The elements of Claim 35 invention of this case are "a search card with multiple contact points on the face of Nos. 1, 2, and 1," which is "Ap. 1', "P. 2'," "P. 2'," "C. 3'," and "P. 4'," which are "P. 3's multiple-story plates (110)" on the upper part, and the search card of Claim 35 (5) invention of this case is "ap. 5's outer circuit board (510)" and "ap. 3's outer circuit board is composed of multiple contact points on the upper part, and (b) a number of printed circuit plates composed of two parallels (510) which can be contacted by members of the D. 1's P. 3's outer circuit, and (c) the examination team composed of two parallels (5. 2' prior to comparison.

B) Invention 2 of the instant Claim 35 is composed of 0 pages 1, 2, 2, and 1 adjacent to the first page of the instant Claim 1, which is composed of multiple number of size 1, which is extended from the first page (Spanch 4) 1, 2, 3, 4, 4, 5, 4, 5, 5, 5, 6, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 1, 5, and, 5.

However, under the description of the invention of this case (see No. 9 of evidence No. 1, No. 27-36 of this case), the Spanish 35 structure is installed and fixed on the supporting floor, and there is a difference in that the composition corresponding to comparable invention No. 1 through No. 3 has been used as a tamper of search. Thus, according to the description of the invention of this case (see, e.g., No. 9 of evidence No. 1) that "the structure of the instant Claim No. 35 has a tample structure of each of the semiconductors (the search elements) that is not a certain semiconductor structure, and that the other part has a certain length extended to the supporting floor so that it can not be seen that it can be seen that there is a tample structure formed by free contact structure of each of the search components formed by free contact factors.

However, the specification of the invention of this case (see subparagraph 1 No. 4 to 5, No. 7, No. 33 to 36) is published in the existing search card assembly, indicating that it is included in or has the same structure as 'franchis contact structure', and only 10-franchis contact points (13), one-day only part of which is installed on the card board (11) that is composed of 10-franchis contact points and 10-franchis contact points (referring to 11-franchis contact points) that are composed of 10-franchis contact points and 10-franchis contact points (referring to 13-franchis contact points), so as to create free contact points (referring to 10-franchis contact points) with 13-franchis contact points (referring to 13-franchis contact points).

On the other hand, the structure of the instant Claim No. 35 invention is installed in Spanish franchise (506) and the structure corresponding to the comparable invention No. 1 through No. 4 is attached to a set of pans (or a fluor, an inspector (2), a transparent board (3), or a flag board for skin expansion (101,201). According to the description of the instant Claim No. 35 in light of the description, the Spanish of the instant Claim No. 35 was attached on the set of Spain (or a fluor: a spatial transformation; a fluor, a fluoring, a fluoring, a fluoring (3), or a fluoring board (101,201).

In light of the structure of comparable invention 1 and the size of comparable invention 1 and the size of comparable invention 1 (520) under the upper part (522) of comparable invention 1 and the size of the lower part (520 separation distance between Pitch and short part) are composed of changes (52), and the size of the lower part (522) is more than that of the lower part, and the transparent board of comparable invention 3 is composed of a group of members of comparable invention 1 and the size of comparable invention 1 in comparison with the size of the lower part (52). However, there is a difference between the size of comparable invention 1 and the size of comparable invention 1 in terms of the size of comparable invention 1 and the size of the upper part (50.2) of the size of comparable invention 4 in comparison with the size of the upper part (1) the size of the upper part (1) the size of the size of the prior art invention 4 in comparison with the size of the upper part (5.2).

C) The elements of Claim 35 invention are linked to multiple contact points of 1,00,00,000 (1114) 1,00,000,000 or 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,0000,000,000,000,000,000,0000,000,000,000,00,000,00,000,00.

d) The elements of the instant Claim 35 are means to adjust the franchis distribution of semiconductor 2 to the Spanish chis distribution cards without changing the franchis distribution of the chis distribution card, which are means of controlling the franchis distribution of semiconductor 1 from comparable inventions 2 to the surface of semiconductor 2, ensuring the franchis distribution of semiconductor franchis (2) surface surface of semiconductor 2, which are non-franchis distribution of semiconductor chis distribution and (3) transparent franchis distribution of semiconductor chis distribution to the non-franchis distribution of semiconductors (536,538) and to adjust the franchis distribution of semiconductors to the non-franchis distribution of non-franchis distribution of non-s distribution 2, which are non-franchis distribution of non-s distribution franchis distribution 524).

The composition of the Claim 35 invention in this case is different in the sense that (14) the tweet (11) of the semiconductorwaferfer (12) in the event that a tweet in contact with the voltage of the electric tweet (12) of the semiconductorwafer (11), the tweet (13) of the tweet (13) is changed to the course of the inspection board (2) on the ground that the tweet (2) is tweetly changed to the course of the inspection board (2).

However, Spanish 35 Invention 5 (506) is composed of a fluor of the lower part (520) of the size of the lower part (522) and a change in the size of the lower part (522), while the transparent board of comparable invention 1 and comparable invention 3 are different in that the size of the fluor of comparable invention 2 can not be changed, as seen earlier, a change in the size of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the fluor of the f.

이에 대하여 피고는, 비교대상발명 1의 미세 조절나사는 멤브레인의 배향을 변경하는 구성이 아니라 탐침카드를 구성하는 PCB 기판, 평면조절판 등의 부품들을 상호 ‘ 체결하는 기능을 수행하는 것이고, 비교대상발명 1에 기재된 “ coarse vertical adjustment " 라는 용어가 기재되어 있으나 이는 멤브레인 카드의 기술적, 구조적 한계를 고려할 때 전체적 평면성 ( gross / global planrization ) 과 관련된 것이라기보다는 국부적 평면성 ( local planarization ) 에 관련된 것으로 보아야 하므로, 이 사건 발명에서 전체적인 평면성 ' 을 달성하는 기능을 수행하는 배향조정수단과는 차이가 있다고 주장하므로 살피건대, 비교대상발명 1에 “ 미세조절나사를 갖는 평면판은 탄성고무판을 통해 멤브레인을 지지해주며 반도체와의 사이에 균등한 압력을 주도록 되어 있다. 1 ~ 2mil 이내의 거친 평면성 조절에 사용한다 " ( 갑 제4호증의 제22쪽 제13 ~ 18줄 참조 ), “ 박막 웨이퍼 탐침검사 시스템의 모듈 조립체는 평탄화 조정 및 X - Y 배향조정을 용이하게 한다. 평탄도에 있어서의 미세한 변동을 흡수하는 광학적 투명 탄성체에 의해 시료 ( DUT ) 에 대한 박막 테스트 카드의 배향 조정이 용이하게 된다. 평탄화 나사에 의해 거친 수직 방향의 조정 ( coarse vertical adjustement ) 이 행해진다 " ( 갑 제4호증의 제21쪽 그림 6. 의 하단 설명 부분 참조 ) 라고 기재되어 있고, 그 그림 6. 과 그림 31. 에 미세 조절나사가 평면판 , PCB 기판 및 멤브레인이 접착된 베크라이트 ( bakelite ) 에 체결되어 있는 멤브레인 카드 조립체의 구성이 도시되어 있는 바, 비록 미세 조절나사의 동작원리 등에 관하여 구체적으로 기재되어 있지는 않으나, 이 사건 발명이 속하는 기술분야에서 통상의 지식을 가진 자라면, 위 기재 및 도시 내용으로부터, 비교대상발명 1의 미세 조절나사는 멤브 레인 카드 조립체의 조립시 부품들을 체결하는 기능을 수행하는 동시에, 그 기술용어 “ 미세 조절 나사 ” 또는 “ 평탄화 나사 ” 가 의미하는 바대로, 평면판에 구비된 미세 조절나사 즉, 평탄화 나사를 좌우로 회전시킴으로써, 멤브레인의 수직 방향의 배향을 미세하게 조절하여 반도체 웨이퍼 또는 PCB 기판에 대한 멤브레인의 평면성을 조절하는 기능도 수행하는 것이라는 점, 또한 국부적 평면성이라는 것은 탄성을 가진 개개의 탐침요소가 반도체 다이 상의 대응되는 전극패드에 접촉할 때, 접촉압력에 의한 탄성 변형이 이루어져 반도체 다이 패드들 또는 탐침요소 팁들의 개별적인 높이 차이를 국부적으로 보상하는 개념인데, 비교대상발명 1의 멤브레인에 부착된 범프는 비탄성의 탐침요소이기 때문에 국부적 평면성을 달성할 수 없는 것은 자명한 사항이라는 점, 더 나아가 갑 제10호증에 “ 원형 헤드에 결합된 4개의 조절나사 ( S1 ~ S4 ) 를 회전시킴으로써 , IC 장치의 모든 접촉패드 ( 17 ) 와 프로브 조립체의 멤브레인 ( 13 ) 의 접촉영역의 면이 정확히 평행한 면을 이루도록 하여 원하는 평행성을 달성하는 기술 ” ( 갑 제10호증의 칼럼 9 “ 평탄화 ( Planarization ), 부분 요약, 도면 제3도 참조 ) 이 개시되어 있어, 멤브레인 타입의 프로브 조립체에서도 조절나사에 의하여 전체적 평면성을 달성할 수 있는 것임을 알 수 있는 점에 비추어, 비교대상발명 1에서 미세 조절나사 또는 평탄화 나사의 조절에 의하여 멤브레인의 배향을 조정하는 것은 탐침기능을 수행하는 범프가 부착된 멤브 레인의 전체적 평면성을 달성하기 위한 것이고, 이에 따라서 “ coarse vertical adjustment " 라는 용어도 전체적 평면성과 관련된 것으로 보아야 하므로, 피고의 위 주장은 이유 없다 .

(3) Preparation for effects of action

The instant Claim 35 invention consists of Spanish tampers and colonies with tampers with tampers and tampers with tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' tampers' 2 and 4, as seen in comparison with the aforementioned tampers' tampers' 2, 2, and 3, tample or tampers' tampers' tampers' 2.

As to this, the defendant asserts that the search card assembly based on the invention of this case does not include the composition directly related to the above effect claimed by the defendant, and if it can achieve the same effect only with the composition described in paragraph 35 invention of this case, it is clear that the combination of comparable inventions that can be used in the composition of Claim 35 invention of this case can achieve the same effect as the defendant's assertion, since the defendant's assertion is without merit, it is clear that the combination of comparable inventions that can be used in the composition of Claim 35 invention of this case can achieve the same effect as that of the defendant's assertion.

(4) The summary of the comparison results is the same as that of the comparable invention 1 through 4, and the purpose of the comparison is substantially the same as that of the comparable invention 1 through 3. In the composition, the elements of the Claim 35 invention of this case are substantially the same as that of the comparable invention 1 through 4, and the elements 2 and 3 can be combined with the composition corresponding to the comparable invention 2 and 4, and the same as those of the comparable invention 1 and 3 can be changed. The elements 4 are the same as those of the comparable invention 1 and 3. Thus, the Claim 35 invention of this case is deemed to be easily made by a person with ordinary knowledge in the technical field to which the invention of this case belongs, from the combination of the comparable invention 1, 3 and the comparable invention 2 and 4.

In order to determine the inventive step of a patent invention by citing various prior art documents, the Defendant presented the motive that the patent invention can be patented if combined with the prior art documents. The cited inventions in the instant case asserted that the combinations with the inventions in the instant case cannot deny the inventive step of the invention by the combination of comparable inventions since the combinations with the inventions in the instant case are not entirely suggested or inappropriate. However, both the inventions and the comparable inventions in the instant case are related to the assembling of prob cards or search cards, and in order to inspect semiconductor devices, all of the contact points of semiconductor devices are practically the same size, so it is essential for all of the contact points of semiconductors to make the contact points of semiconductors in the technical field equal to those of semiconductors, and it is not necessary for the combinations of semiconductor devices and prob cards to accomplish the purpose of the prior inventions in the instant case, and thus, it is not necessary for the combinations with the prior art to achieve the purpose of the prior inventions in the instant case, and it is not necessary for the combinations with the prior art to achieve such objective and the purpose of the prior inventions.

In addition, the defendant asserts that the invention of this case was made available for the first time as a member (Mams and Micro Emsctic Emsplate) assembly, and that the product implemented has commercial success, and thus its inventive step should be recognized. However, the commercial success of the product implemented by the invention is used as a supplementary material for the determination of inventive step, and it cannot be determined by itself as to the inventive step of the invention. As seen earlier, as long as the invention of this case is found to have no inventive step compared to the cited inventions in its purpose, composition, and operating effect, the conclusion may not vary depending on commercial success. Thus, the above argument is without merit.

D. Whether the instant Claim Nos. 31, 39, and 43 inventions are recognized as non-obviousness compared to the comparable inventions (1) inventions of this case, compared to the instant Claim Nos. 35 inventions as seen earlier, according to the claim Nos. 31 inventions of this case, there is a difference between the 4 elements of the instant Claim Nos. 35 inventions of this case, without changing the direction of the search confirmation card, and there is an adjustment method to the search identification card. Thus, the instant Claim Nos. 31 inventions of this case can be easily described by a person with ordinary knowledge in the art to which the instant invention pertains, from comparable inventions 2 and 4.

(2) According to the claim(s) claim(s) of this case, the claim(s) of this case’s Claim(s) is that the scope of the contact structure is widened by changing Spain with multiple contact windows attached on Nos. 1, 2, 2, and 1, which are linked to the elements of the claim(s) of this case’s Claim(s) to “the multiple contact downloads attached on No. 31, 2, 2, and Spain structures extension from No. 1, which are extended from No. 1, and extended from No. 1,” among the elements of the claim(s) of this case’s Claim(s) to “the multiple contact downloads attached on No. 31, 2, 2, and 1, which are adjoining to the elements of the claim(s) of this case’s Claim(s). Accordingly, a person having ordinary knowledge in the technology of this case can easily make an invention from comparable inventions(s) 2 and 4.

(3) The Claim No. 43 invention of this case is a subordinate claim citing Claim No. 39. The claim No. 39 invention of this case is a characteristic of including the conciliation method to adjust Spanish franchise's distribution to the search card without changing the distribution of the search card. However, as seen earlier, the Claim No. 43 invention of this case, which added the above elements to Claim No. 39 invention of this case, is the same as the Claim No. 35 invention of this case, on the ground that it had already been examined in the above C., a person with ordinary knowledge in the art to which the invention of this case belongs, can easily make inventions from combinations between Invention No. 1, 3, 2, and 4 with comparable invention No. 1, 39.

E. According to the claim 70 of the instant Claim 1, the non-obviousness of the instant Claim 1, which is recognized as a non-obviousness of the instant Claim 2, includes (1) search cards to provide a studioless electrical contact points to the vexetator (2) search devices on the non-obviousness 1, and (3) search devices on the non-obviousness 2 of the instant Claim 1, which are linked to the non-obviousness 1, 2) search devices on the non-obviousness 5 (the non-obviousness 1) search devices on the non-obviousness 2 of the instant Claim 70 (the non-obviousness 1) search devices on the non-obviousness 2 of the non-obviousness vexetet-to-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-exp-ex-ex-exp-exp-ex.

However, since the search of the instant Claim 70 invention was provided by the Department 1 on the 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 1st 2nd 2nd 2nd 1st 2nd 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 2nd 1st 2nd 2nd 1st 2nd 2nd 1st 3st 2nd 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 2nd 1st 2nd 3st 2nd 2nd 1st 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 3nd 2nd 3nd 2nd 2nd 2nd 3

(4) Accordingly, the instant Claim 70 invention could easily be made by a person with ordinary knowledge in the technical field to which the instant invention pertains from the combinations between comparable inventions 2 or comparable inventions 2 and comparable inventions 1, 3, and 4.

(h) The invention of paragraph 72 of this case is an invention described in the dependent claim 70 citing the claim 70 of this case. In the invention of paragraph 70 of this case, it is characterized by adding additional means to change the direction of the search board to the above search board assembly of the invention of paragraph 72 of this case (536,538) the search search board (524) of this case is installed by changing the direction of the search search board (506) to the non-obviousness of the non-obviousness of the invention of paragraph 72 of this case (502) to the non-obviousness of the non-obviousness of the invention of this case. It is also necessary to adjust the composition of the non-obviousness of the non-obviousness invention of paragraph 72 of this case to the non-obviousness of the non-obviousness invention of paragraph 72 of this case (the non-obviousness of the non-obviousness invention of the non-obviousness invention of this case to the non-obviousness 2 of the non-obviousness invention of the non-obviousness 3 of the non-obviousness 1 of the non-obviousness 2 of the non-art.

G. Whether the instant Claim 73 invention is recognized as non-obviousness compared with the cited inventions, the instant Claim 73 invention can be identified by the assembly of search cards, characterized by (1) search cards containing multiple electrical contacts, (2) the aforementioned search cards are fixed and fixed, and multiple tensions search search factors are included, and the said tensions (3) the search inquiry factors are included in the search cards, which are linked with the above contacts, including the mobile elements posted to change the course of the search response.

(1) In the assembly of the search card, which is the first component of the instant Claim 73 invention, the “Search card, including multiple electric contacts,” corresponds to the “PCB flag board of comparable invention 1,” the “prob card board of comparable invention 2,” the “prob card board of comparable invention 3,” and the “multi-story board of comparable invention 4,” and the “multi-story board of comparable invention 4 (110).” The composition corresponding to the said invention is all the same composition in that it carries out a painting function to input the electric signals detected in the search card assembly into the main body of the inspection device.

(2) The second element of the Claim 73 invention of this case is fixed to make it possible to move to the above search card, including a number of tensiond coal search factors, and the above tensiond coal search factors are to connect the tension search factors to the semiconductor wafers (526) that are corresponding to the semiconductor wafers by having contacted the tension search elements into the semiconductor wafers (526) and electronically connect the electrical signals searched from the semiconductor wafers to the search card, which is a group of members transmitting the electrical signals detected from the semiconductor IC using the pande from the comparable invention 1 to the PC, and (3) connect the same characteristics as the chip from the comparable invention 2 to the electrical electrical chip (14) by removing the electrical signals from the semiconductor wafers (14) through the electrical chip's electrical chip.

However, the search exploration floor of the instant Claim 73 invention includes a tensiond coal search factors, while the composition corresponding to the cited inventions 1 through 3 is different from the use of a pans or a pansculic electric field as a search factor. However, as seen in the above E. 2., from the assembly of search cards, the formation of search intrusion in contact with the semiconductor waferer’s semiconductor wafer is merely an widely known art.

(3) The mobile elements of the 73 invention of this case, which are the third component of the invention of this case, assigned to change the direction of the search base to the above search base, are to adjust the course of the search base (506) installed in the search base (502) by changing the direction of the search base (506) and adjusting the direction of the search base to the search base (502), so that all of the tampers of the search base may have the accurate contact with the semiconductor 1 at the same time, and the 3rd invention of comparable invention of this case (the 3rd invention of this case is composed of the combination 4th invention of comparable invention) which is equipped with the carbon rubber board and the flat board, and the 2nd invention of comparable invention of this case (the 3rd invention of this case, which is marked as a combination of semiconductor 1) which is equipped with the 3rd invention of this case by controlling the reputation of the members of wafer or PC, and the 3rd invention of this case.

H. Whether the instant Claim No. 82 invention is recognized as non-obviousness compared to the comparable inventions, the instant Claim No. 82 invention is an invention described in the subordinate claim citing Claim No. 73, which is described in the instant Claim No. 73 invention with the characteristics of Spain including Spain franchises. However, it is composed of Spain franchises, such as the instant Claim No. 82 invention, with the feature of Spain, which makes changes in the search beer layer as in the instant Claim No. 82. The structure of the exhaustton (5a) formed on the upper upper upper part of the test board (2) and the upper part of the test board (14) in the comparable invention No. 2, changing the skin between the difference between the two (5a) and the main part (101) in the comparable invention No. 4.

Inasmuch as the instant Claim 82 was publicly announced by a composition that alters the skin by forming differently the arrangement avoidance of metal teams (109) and U.S. P. P.P. (8) established on the upper and lower sides of the invention, it would be easy for a person with ordinary knowledge in the technical field to easily make an invention from the combination between comparable invention 1, 3, and comparable invention 2, and comparable invention 4.

In regard to this, the defendant, among the elements of the invention of paragraph 82 of this case, means that "the above 1st century is fixed to the above search card, including multiple tension search factors," and "the above search betwelth" and "the above search betwelth" containing the above contact and electrical twelthic twelthic twelthic swelthic swelthic swelths, "Ilvely fixed" among the above elements, are able to change their direction toward the search card by the movement of "Swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic swelthic s weld s we can find.

I. According to the claim(s) inventions of this case as to whether the nonobviousness of the instant claim(84) invention is recognized compared to the cited inventions, the elements of the claim(s) are as follows: (i) search card devices to provide twits to semiconductor testers, (ii) multiple tensions of electronically communicating with the above search card devices, and (iii) the above search card devices include the device fixed to enable the above search card devices to move, and (iv) the above search card devices to change the direction of the above search card devices, and thus, it is very different from the instant claim(s) inventions, and thus, it is easy for a person with ordinary knowledge in the art to easily make the invention from combinations with comparable inventions 1, 3, or 1, 3, or 3 and comparable inventions 2, and 4.

j. Sub-committee

Therefore, the nonobviousness of the instant invention is denied in light of the cited inventions, and its registration shall be invalidated in accordance with Articles 29(2) and 133(1)1 of the Patent Act, and the part related to each of the instant invention is unlawful in conclusion.

4. Conclusion

Thus, among the decision of this case, the plaintiff's claim of this case seeking the revocation of the part concerning the invention of this case Nos. 31, 35, 39, 43, 70, 72, 73, 82 and 84 of this case is reasonable, and it is so decided as per Disposition by the assent of all participating Justices.

Judge Park Dong-dong

Judges Doing-type

Judges Kim Young-young

Attached 1. The invention of this case

(a) Claims;

Claim 31. Search cards with multiple contact points on the face 1, 2, and 1, and Nos. 1

Multiple contact tagss placed on the face Myeon, 2, 2 and 1 attached adjacent to the face 1

Spanish with a structure with PPS 1 Pream Contacts extended from the face;

including franchises, and multiple contact tagss are connected to multiple contact points of the search cards;

A search card assembly with the characteristics of the information.

In claim 35.31, in paragraph 31, Spanish franchise without changing the course of the search card.

s) Search with a characteristic of including adjustment measures against the search cards.

Mad Card assembly.

Claim 39. Search Card with multiple contact points in the face 1, 2, and 1, and 1

Multiple contact tagss placed on the face Myeon, 2, 2 and 1 attached adjacent to the face 1

Spain with a structure of contact with multiple structures extended from the surface of the earth, including Spanpans franchises;

more than one contact tags are connected to the multiple contact points of the search card.

the tampling entity of the search card.

Pursuant to Claim 43.39, the Ppanish franchise without changing the course of the search card.

s) Search with a characteristic of including adjustment measures against the search cards.

Mad Card assembly.

70. Search for providing electrical contact points to a tester for assembly of search cards

Soverline means and means of card; search for the provision of longer space electric contact points in the experimental semiconductor devices;

The means and means of bedion; . The change of the direction of the above search cards to the above search cards;

at the location of the above search card and the above search bed by electrical connection;

A search card assembly with characteristics, including one cross-connection.

In Claim 72.70, for claims 72.70, the above search reporting device means:

Search cards with characteristics of including additional means to change the course of service

73. In assembly of a search card, a search card containing multiple electrical contacts

J. . Shall be fixed to the above search card and contain multiple longer tension search factors.

(2) The above elements of the search of the coal shall be the first floor and the second floor of the search communication with the above contact;

Having indicated on the search card, a portable element that is placed to change the course of the search team at the above time.

Then, the search card assembly with the characteristics of the information.

82. In Claim 82.73, the above search compromise includes Spanish franchises.

the search card assembly with the characteristics of this section.

84. In assembly of search cards, provision of seals to semiconductor testers

the means and means of the search card for such purpose; and multiple tensions that communicate with the said search card means and electrically;

support their inquiry factors, and means of studios fixed to enable their movement to the above search card means; and

(1) include any means to change the course of the aforesaid means of tampling to the preceding means of tamping

A search card assembly with the characteristics of the information.

(Other claims are omitted)

(b) Drawings (representative drawings);

Do4

400

A person shall be appointed.

Do5

500

* The Roster (504) appearing in Do 5 is limited to tampers (502) and Tampers (544, 504).

For access to the invention of this case, description as a component of Claim No. 1 of the invention of this case

As such, it is not directly related to the claims at issue in the lawsuit at issue in this case; and

However, it can be seen as a practice of the interconnection means under Claim 70.

Attached 2. Invention 2.

1. Invention 1;

A. Summary of the invention

The Korean Institute of Machinery and Technology No. 4 prepared around March 1992 by the Korean Institute of Science and Technology No. 4

The invention described in the final report on the development of the manufacturing technology of the Meembrae

in this chapter, the summary of the “member sob cards” is a flat board, PCB (printed circuits) equipped with mina control or history.

Rogboards), coal rubber plates, and members with panscules attached, and search and inspection of boomers.

The framework assembly of the system shall facilitate the adjustment of flatization and X - Y exhausting coordination, and shall be in the flat map.

a sample (DUT, Device UN) by a optical transparent carbon that absorbs a detailed change

Test. Emp. H. H. H. A. H. H. H. T. H. H. T. H. T. H. T. H. T. H. T. H. H. T

a member, through a coal rubber board, support the members of the group, and make equal pressure between semiconductors.

It is known that it is used for the adjustment of equilibrium that has been replaced by not more than one to two meters."

(2).

(b) Drawings;

forest 6 Afforestation 31

A person shall be appointed.

2. Invention 2

A. Summary of the invention

The Japanese Patent Gazette No. 5 - The semiconductors described in the Japanese Patent Gazette No. 29406 (Publication of February 5, 1993)

In the case of an invention with respect to a testing device, the substance of the invention is “the previous technology is the surface and inspection of semiconductor wafer (11).”

In the event that the reputation of the surface of the fraud board (2) is not secured, the tearsen (7) and the tearsen (12) and the electric power;

However, there was a problem that the reliability of the prosecutor was deteriorated because the prosecutor did not sufficiently obtain sufficient contact;

This invention, in semiconductor inspection devices, is subject to either (1) or (14) or (14) or subject to such device.

(2) The number of Preamble cards (1) with Preamble cards (1) and inspection board (2) with Preamble lines (13) connected to each other and (1) with Preamble cards, each of which is accompanied by

(1) by adopting the composition connecting B. B. and B. B. P. P. P. P. P.T. T. (13) with P.P. T.T.

The card (1) is subject to the coordination of the slope of the inspection board (2) on the card, and accordingly, on the semiconductor wafer.

The reliability of the inspection shall be secured by a good electrical contact with the trode of the electric circuit and the inspection board to ensure the reliability of the inspection.

It can be known that the improvement is "......."

(b) Drawings;

Do1 Do1 3

1: 53, 5byty

2: 13 I

A: cents 14 :

Do6

3. Invention 3

A. Summary of the invention

Japan Patent No. 6 No. 3- 65659 (Disclosure of March 20, 1991) 'proba

D as an invention related to “D”, its summary “in case of a prob card, card board (2), auxiliary board (5), buffer board (5),”

(6) In the absence of (6), (3), and (7) for flat coordination, the auxiliary board is equipped with a transparent board attached with a panf, and (7) for flat coordination;

(5) The line board (7) set up on the card board (2) by turning back to the right or the right or right or right or right or the right or right or right or right or the right or right or right or right or right or right or right or right or right or right or right

A. (5) Contact with A. B. H. H. H. H. H. H. H. H. H.D., and due to its lectures, the foregoing paragraph (3) is not a buffer

It is known that it is "a coordination in the parallel shape throughout the world."

(b) Drawings;

Do3

A person shall be appointed.

4. Invention 4

A. Summary of the invention

No. 8 of Japan Patent No. 6-5090 (Disclosure February 25, 1994)

In the case of the card "B", the summary of the card is "not equivalent to the failure of the semiconductor integrated circuit."

Pursuant to paragraph (1) of this Article, a machine for the expansion of fix plates, such as red-story plates (101) shall be avoided on one side.

Preparation of metal plates (104) consisting of arrangements identical to the arrangement of the measurement chip (102) par (103) ;

Any person who directly or indirectly connects the metal set (104) to the prob, with a vertical link, and the prob.

Madin 105) Finbrobed with each other (106 to 108) metal circuits (104) by virtue of 106 to 108

Linked or consisting of finine (205) directly connected to metal shorts (204) by means of a dam water supply, etc.

agency may be known to the public.

(b) Drawings;

Do 1 Do 2

A person shall be appointed.

Attached 3. Other Evidence

1. Evidence No. 7;

A. Summary of the invention

Japan Patent No. 1 - 150862 (Disclosure, 1989, 13 June 13), “prob card” described in “prob card”

As an invention, the summary of the " multiple contact points prepared on a prob card board" shall be each of the semiconductor devices.

In connection with the protocol card that contacts the electric circuit and inspects the electric signal by entering and printing it, a probb,

1) The card board (11) set up multiple electric lines (12) on the face, and the group of such electric lines (12).

B clb card board (11) form a flblblin type contacter (13) with flblblin type

each contactr (13) even if there is a difference in height of electric power failure (6) formed in semiconductor devices (5).

It can be known that “technology” is “a technology that makes it possible to have good contact by having shot contact with the former (6).

(b) Drawings;

Do2

A person shall be appointed.

4:

S:IN

4 : 電播心9F

2. Evidence No. 10

A. Summary of the invention

Inspection of integrated circuits devices listed in the Patent Gazette No. 5, 355, 079 (Public Notice of October 11, 1994) of the United States of America

The invention of "prob assembly" for the purpose of this, the summary of which is "the search card assembly shall be PCB (10)," and

Members (13), members (14), members of contact with string (F), members of contact with string (14), galivities (15), and 4

Jinna (S1 to S4) as a major component, and all sping contacts to inspect the ICT device.

Contacping is to have contact with all contact seals of the ICT device by force of the same size substantially.

It is essential to ensure that the area of contact is subject to the removal of the ICT device as soon as possible, and the ICT device.

and where there is a difference in official space because the face area of contact between the search card assembly and the search card assembly is not accurately balanced;

S1-S4) To achieve the desired balance, four controlnas (S1-S4) incorporated into the original HD

It is possible to make necessary amendments by making it possible to do so.

(b) Drawings;

Do2

A person shall be appointed.