1. The Defendants jointly share KRW 2,00,000 for each of the Plaintiffs, and the same from May 3, 2016 to December 20, 2018.

1. Basic facts

A. Defendant I is the head of the general affairs division of the P Women’s Hospital located in Sungwon-siO in Changwon-si, and Defendant J is the operator of the P Women’s Hospital.

Plaintiff

C, D, B, and A are the operators of the R Women's Hospital located in Q from the window of Changwon-si, and the operators of the Plaintiff G, H, E, and F are the operators of the R Postnatal Care Center located in Q from the window of Changwon-si.

B. The R Women’s Hospital and R Postnatal Care Center were imposed an administrative fine by the Ministry of Food and Drug on the ground that they stored products whose distribution period has expired for cooking, and that such fact was disclosed to the news report materials of April 14, 2016, and the fact was reported under their real names on many Internet news around that time.

다. 이에 피고 I는 2016. 4. 15. P여성병원 사무실에서 네이버 카페 ‘M’에 P여성병원 여직원 S 명의로 가입된 아이디 T로 접속하여 'U'이라는 닉네임으로 “V”라는 제목으로 “‘유통기한 8개월 지난 제품 보관’ 산후조리원 괜찮을까”라는 기사의 내용을 인용하면서 “R 얼마 전부터 계속 삐걱거리는 소리 들리더니 (후략)”라는 본문글을 게시하고, 같은 날 15:36경 위 본문글에 “식품의약품안전처 들어가면 명단 떠요;; 45곳 중 으뜸으로 꼽혔네요;;; 자랑스럽네요 참나”라는 댓글을, 같은 날 15:37경"맞아요.

Ethiopia:

(m) It is necessary to keep food and drink.

Such whites

(o) Mascopic fluscopic fluscopher도요

“Written comments”, at 16:03 on the same day, whether “Ne, if any, a hospital; and

A notice on the comments "I am far away," and the closed user of W "W" posts the comments "I am under the management of food," and "I am under the direction of the first X.

Y인가요 ㅜㅜ

”라는 댓글을 게시하자 같은 날 15:35경 “앞이요;;; 8개월”이라는 댓글을 게시하였다. 피고 I는 계속하여 닉네임을 ‘Z’으로 변경한 다음 같은 날 16:15경 위 본문글에 “헙 ㅠㅠㅠ...