1. The plaintiff's claims against the defendants are all dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. Basic facts

A. The Plaintiff operated a certified tax accountant office as a certified tax accountant, but the Plaintiff did not settle the debt arising from the loan guarantee, resulting in bad credit standing, and Defendant B employed Defendant B as the head of the office of the Plaintiff’s office around January 200, as a result, difficult to operate the office. In addition, the Plaintiff left Defendant B as the head of the Plaintiff’s office.

B. Around that time, Defendant B maintained de facto marital relationship with the Plaintiff’s father-child, but D was also involved in the business of paying wages to employees and managing the passbook of the Plaintiff’s office as the head of the office of the Plaintiff, and was subject to criminal punishment due to the omission of the value-added tax of the company separately operated around 2007, and thereafter, Defendant B operated the Plaintiff’s office solely.

C. During the operation of the Plaintiff’s office, Defendant B had worked at each office, and had an overall report on the operation of the office from Defendant B. Defendant B transferred the monthly price of KRW 100,000 to KRW 1.5 million to the Plaintiff, and Defendant B transferred the monthly price of KRW 12,000 to KRW 15,000 to KRW 1.5 million to the Plaintiff on May of each year with tax adjustment.

In addition, after release D from the office of the plaintiff, the defendant B retired from office on January 2012 due to the infertility while working again at the plaintiff office.

E. Defendant C Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “Defendant Co., Ltd”) is the representative director of Defendant B, a company established on February 8, 2010 for the purpose of wholesale and retail business, such as curios and calligraphic books.

[Ground of recognition] Unsatisfy, Gap evidence 15-1, 2, Gap evidence 28-12, Eul evidence 1, 10, 11-2, Eul evidence 1, part of Eul evidence 17, witness E's testimony, the result of this court's order to submit financial transaction information to Nonghyup Bank, the whole purport of pleadings

2. Assertion and determination

A. At the time when Defendant B’s claim against Defendant B against the gist of the Plaintiff’s claim serves as the head of the Plaintiff’s office, the Plaintiff was in bad credit standing.