Text
1. The plaintiffs' claims against the defendant are all dismissed.
2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.
Reasons
1. Facts of recognition;
A. The Plaintiffs are children between F and G.
B. The Seongbuk-gu Seoul H third-class housing (hereinafter “instant housing”) owned 1/5 shares in each of the Plaintiffs, F, and G. However, on November 11, 2009, the total sum of equity interests of the Plaintiffs and G was transferred to F on the ground of donation (hereinafter “instant transfer registration”), and F completed the registration of ownership transfer to the Defendant on the ground of sale on August 4, 201.
C. The land and a building on the ground of H large H 354 square meters was owned by the Plaintiffs, F, and G, which were donated by the Plaintiffs, F, and G on September 26, 1986 (However, the land was disposed of by F alone on June 2, 1992). Since the land was divided into J 156 square meters in the above H, the said J land (hereinafter “instant J land”) was divided into one fifth share in each of the Plaintiffs, F, and G, and the building was owned by F alone.
However, one-fifth of the shares of G among the instant J land was transferred to F on the ground of donation at the same time as the instant transfer registration, and the instant J land and the instant building were sold to the Defendant at the auction procedure on June 20, 201.
G filed a divorce lawsuit against F on November 2010.
E. On February 23, 2011, G alleged that the instant transfer registration was in accordance with the foregoing Article, and filed a complaint with G on charges of forging private documents, etc., and the same year.
5.2. Around February, 200, one fifth of the J lands of this case added the contents of the complaint under the same suspicion.
On October 18, 2011, the Seoul Central District Prosecutors' Office imposed a disposition that was suspected of being F on October 18, 201, and at the same time, "Facts G and F paid the Plaintiff B's study expenses in U.S., instead of paying the Plaintiff B's study expenses, the Seoul Central District Prosecutors' Office agreed to transfer the instant house and the instant J land to F's shares to F in accordance with the agreement.
Nevertheless, G has F.F.