beta
Text
1. Revocation of the first instance judgment.
2. The Plaintiff’s obligations against the Defendant:
A. On June 23, 2015, Yongsan-gu Seoul around 22:30
Reasons
1. Summary of the plaintiff's assertion
A. The Plaintiff is each insurer of B vehicles (hereinafter referred to as “one vehicle”), E vehicles (hereinafter referred to as “2 vehicles”), F vehicles (hereinafter referred to as “3 vehicles”) and G vehicles (hereinafter referred to as “4 vehicles”), and the Defendant is a person who repairs each damaged vehicle of the traffic accidents caused by the said vehicles and leases and leases other wheeled vehicles during the repair period.
B. In relation to the traffic accidents caused by one vehicle and two vehicles to the Plaintiff, the Defendant claims payment of each damaged vehicle of KRW 3,600,000 for each repair period of up to 30 days, and in relation to the traffic accidents caused by three vehicles, KRW 6,00,000 for the rental fee of up to 30 days during the repair period, and in relation to the traffic accidents caused by four vehicles, KRW 5,788,200 for the repair cost of the damaged vehicle and KRW 4,50,000 for the rental fee of up to 30 days during the repair period.
C. However, since it is reasonable to deem that the appropriate repair period of each damaged vehicle is three days, the rent shall be recognized only for the part corresponding to three days (one day 5,900 won). In light of the negligence of each damaged vehicle (10% for the damaged vehicle by one vehicle, 30% for the damaged vehicle by two vehicles), and the degree of damage, the obligation of the Plaintiff to pay the rent or the repair cost specified in Paragraph (2) of the disposition (167,700 won for the damaged vehicle by four vehicles plus 2,375,00 won for the repair cost). However, the Defendant requires the payment of excessive rent or the repair cost.
Therefore, there is no obligation for the part of the Defendant's loan or repair cost that the Plaintiff requests in excess of the scope of each appropriate loan or repair cost (150,930 won related to the vehicle accident, 117,390 won related to the second vehicle accident, 167,700 won related to the third vehicle accident, and 2,542,70 won in total).