1. Of the judgment of the court of first instance, the part against the plaintiffs falling under the following order of payment shall be revoked.

1. Basic facts

A. (1) Defendant A is a licensed real estate agent operating “F real estate” at the former BK apartment shop during Ansan-si, and Defendant B is an employee of the said brokerage office as the above Defendant’s wife, and Defendant C is a licensed real estate agent operating “H Licensed Real Estate Agent” at the G shopping district located in BL during Ansan-si.

B. The Plaintiff 1 through 21 was recommended by Defendant A and B to acquire the status of a member of the “E Regional Housing Association” (hereinafter “the instant association”) (hereinafter “instant association”) during the course of carrying out the project of constructing the new type of and class 24 and class 32 apartment buildings from the land (hereinafter “instant project site”) in Yeongdeungpo-gu Seoul, Yeongdeungpo-gu, Seoul (hereinafter “instant project site”), and the Plaintiff 22 was recommended by Defendant C to acquire the status of a member of the instant association, and the party who entered into the agreement to join the instant association as a member of the association.

B. (i) The progress of the instant project was planned from the last half of 2001 to promote the instant project in the instant project site, and after establishing the regional housing association for the instant project site, the method of selecting the regional housing association as the enforcement agent from the regional housing association, and prepared to establish the regional housing association on the ground of K. Since the end of 2001, K had prepared to establish the regional housing association on the ground of K and prepared to prepare for the construction of the “tentative E-regional housing association” and the construction of the city.

on April 30, 2003, I and other related companies have entered into an execution agency contract with the content of executing the instant business in the name of the instant partnership, namely, recommendation of the execution company and other related companies, support for the purchase and sale of land, association members, authorization and permission, business related to the operation of the association, contract support, completion and settlement of accounts, etc., which is accompanied by the execution of the instant business in the name of the instant partnership. The I and the stock company on June 21, 2003.