1. The plaintiff's appeal is dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

Purport of claim and appeal

The first instance court.

1. Facts of recognition;

A. As a dentist, the Plaintiff entered into a partnership agreement with I, the representative of the Fental Group, a dental hospital network with 108 branches in the Republic of Korea and 7 branches in the United States (hereinafter “F dental group”), and operates Franchis and G stores.

B. The Defendant Association B (hereinafter “Defendant Association”) is issuing “E” as an incorporated association composed of a Korean dentist’s license holder and a public health doctor. Defendant C is the representative of the Defendant Association and the issuer of E, and Defendant D is the director general of the editing bureau of E.

C. On March 14, 2013, Franchi Group awarded the instant award to the Minister of Health and Welfare (hereinafter “instant award”).

(F brand Sharing Council was confirmed to be an institution subject to the application and deliberation after this, and listing was reissued under the name of the Council. (D)

E on March 28, 2013, published an article in attached Form (hereinafter “instant article”) and the part concerning which the Plaintiff is at issue is as follows.

Now 1 F, this is the 2nd illegal network of title 1 F, the award of which is the first sentence of the F, the first sentence of which is receiving the social landmark by the two representative illegal networks, has led to the authority of the state.

본문 13째줄 4 온갖 탈법과 편법을 벌여 온 F치과 본문 14째줄 5 ‘자뻑 F’ F치과가 F치과 추천 2번째 소제목 6 “F치과의 문제점은 사전에 인지하지 못했다, 사회공헌사업과 관련해 응모를 하면 심사과정을 거쳐 복지부에 상신하는 절차를 밟게 된다”고 밝혔다.

In addition, the recommendations or offers related to social contribution projects are known to have been examined by the parties concerned who will be asked for who will be successful, and the third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third third, and the arguments are made.