beta
Text
1. The part against Defendant B in the judgment of the first instance, including the Plaintiff’s claim reduced in this Court, is as follows.
Reasons
1. Basic facts
A. On the land listed in paragraph (1) of the attached Table 1 of the list of real estate (hereinafter referred to as the “instant land” in the below), the above buildings consisting of three floors above ground (in the registry: a 3-story store in reinforced concrete structure slive roof roof, 230.84m2, 230.84m2, 230.84m2, 30.84m2, 230.84m2 and below, hereinafter referred to as the “instant building”). On the 1st floor of the instant building, there are two separate stores under subparagraphs D through E, 12 of the second and third floors, and one separate store (second floor F & 3 G) on each of the above divided shops are registered as separate independent buildings on the registry.
B. Defendant B is the owner of 276/3,307 shares among the instant land and 1/2 shares among the buildings listed in paragraph (2) of the attached list of real estate (the third floor of the instant building, and hereinafter “the third floor store of this case”). The Plaintiff is the owner of 850/3,307 shares among the instant land and 1/2 shares among the three floors stores of this case. Defendant C is the owner of 443/3,307 shares among the instant land and 443/3,307 shares among the instant land, and Paragraph (3), (4), (5) (the first floor of this case’s building of this case’s 1st floor) of the attached list of real estate (the second floor of this case’s building of this case’s 2nd floor of this case’s building, and the following “the second floor store of this case”).
다. 이 사건 3층 점포의 공유자였던 L은 1996. 4. 16.경 W 명의로 이 사건 3층 점포 중 109.14㎡에 관하여 단란주점 영업허가를 받아 이 사건 3층 점포 일부에서 ‘M’을 운영하다가(1999. 6. 3. L의 처남댁인 피고 B로 영업허가 명의가 변경되었다), 단란주점을 유흥주점으로 바꾸는 내부 인테리어 공사를 마친 후 2001. 10. 16.경 원고의 동생 N 명의로 이 사건 3층 점포 중 74.92㎡에 관하여 유흥주점 영업허가를 받아 이 사건 3층 점포에서 ‘O’ 상호(2003. 11. 15. ‘P’, 2007. 1. 10. ‘Q’으로 상호가 변경되었다)로 유흥주점을 운영하면서 N으로 하여금 그 영업을 관리하게 하였다. 라.
L is related to the operation of entertainment taverns between N around March 2002.