1. The part of the judgment of the court of first instance against the plaintiff, which orders payment below, shall be revoked.

The defendant.

1. Basic facts

A. The plaintiff is a corporation that operates the business of manufacturing shipbuilding machinery such as ship blocks, and the defendant runs the vessel processing business under the trade name of "C".

The plaintiff is operating a vessel block manufacturing factory in Changwon-si Jin-si D, and the defendant also registered his/her business as the location of the same place.

Article 27 (Observance of Regulations on Safety and Health Management) The defendant is responsible for the prevention of industrial accidents in the plaintiff's workplace, and the defendant's specific obligations are as follows:

1. Duty to faithfully observe all the standards prescribed by the Occupational Safety and Health Act;

2. Obligations to faithfully observe and implement all the matters prescribed in the safety and health management regulations of the plaintiff;

3. A duty to faithfully implement the instructions, such as the Plaintiff’s corrective measures and recommendations for improvement, in directed, managing, and supervising the employees of the defendant.

4. Other duties to preserve and promote the lives, safety and health of the employees of the defendant and to prevent safety accidents and industrial accidents.

1. When the Plaintiff deems it necessary, he may supervise the Defendant’s work process of goods under contract and the status of performing the contract, and give necessary instructions, and thereby, the Defendant’s contractual obligation shall not be mitigated.

2. In the event that the cleaning and rearrangement money related to 5S is known, the plaintiff may immediately order the suspension of work, and the defendant shall comply therewith.

Article 30 (Industrial Accidents)

1. regardless of the term of validity of this Agreement, the defendant's work workers and third parties who occurred at the defendant's workplace or at the third place during the delivery of this Agreement shall be liable for any tangible and intangible accidents to the defendant, and the processing of these accidents shall be entirely dealt with at the defendant's expense.

2. In addition to the industrial accident compensation insurance, the defendant's work employees working at the plaintiff's workplace and the third place is an insurance company guaranteeing workers' disaster without exception.