1. All appeals by the Defendants against the Plaintiffs are dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal shall be borne by the Defendants.

1. The reasoning of the court’s explanation concerning this case is as follows, and this case is cited by the main text of Article 420 of the Civil Procedure Act, as it is, except for the following changes and additions.

(In light of the evidence additionally submitted by the Defendant in the trial, it is not different from the fact-finding and judgment of the first instance court, even if it is not different from the fact-finding and judgment).

O. The fourth through twelve pages of the first instance judgment shall be amended as follows:

(C) The employees of Defendant B stored the card customer information received from the Defendant A in the office-based computer, and used it for their business by sharing the stored spons. C copied the card customer information stored in the said sharing spons to Nowon-North Korea that he used for his business, and then transmitted it to E through the data transmission program (FTP; Fil Transfer Program) already installed in the above E-ray. C connects his own USB mp to the computer, and then copied the card customer information stored in the said E-computer’s computer on a remote basis by using the Putty.

“”

O. On the 14th day of the first instance judgment, following the 17th day of the judgment, “it is difficult to identify a specific personal information solely based on the perusal of the disclosed personal information in light of the size of the leaked personal information through the instant information leakage accident, the actual distributed personal information is merely a part of the leaked personal information, and the limitation of corporate compensation should be considered.

"in addition".

O. The 15th and 20th of the first instance judgment shall be amended as follows:

Therefore, according to the former or latter part of Article 756(1) of the Civil Code, Defendant B.