All appeals by the Defendants and the Prosecutor are dismissed.

1. The summary of the grounds for appeal by the Defendants and the Prosecutor asserts that the Defendants’ punishment (two and half years of imprisonment, two and half years of imprisonment, and two years of imprisonment) declared by the lower court against the Defendants is excessive so that the Defendants are unfair, and that the prosecutor is too unfasible and unfair.

2. The Defendants are first offenders, and all of their crimes are recognized, and they do not repeat again.

There are many things.

Defendant

C agreed with some victims in the original trial and the party trial.

그러나 이 사건 사기 범행과 같이 불특정 다수의 피해자를 대상으로 조직적ㆍ계획적으로 이루어지는 전기통신금융 사기 범행( 이른바 ‘ 보이스 피 싱 범행’) 은 특히 경제적 ㆍ 사회적 약자들을 주요 범행 대상으로 삼아 그 궁박한 처지를 이용하여 이들을 더욱 어려운 상황에 이르도록 하는 등 죄질이 매우 나쁠 뿐만 아니라 그 범행 수법이 갈수록 지능화 하는 등 범행이 야기하는 사회적 폐해도 심각하다.

In addition, the above crimes are highly likely to be socially criticized by seriously impairing the trust of the state agencies and financial institutions of the members of society as well as the direct victims.

Moreover, since these crimes are structural characteristics that make it difficult to arrest the entire organization members, it is necessary to eradicate them through strict punishment even if not only those who led the crimes but also those who participated in only part of the crimes.

On the other hand, the defendants would give the victims a loan by calling for a telephone.

Since a direct deception, such as deceiving, was carried out, the degree of participation in the crime is not easy.

Although the victims of the instant crime were victims of considerable damage, damage recovery has not yet been made until the victims (Defendant C agreed with some victims in the first instance, but it is extremely extremely high considering the number of victims and the amount of damage.