1. Of the judgment of the court of first instance, the part against the defendant shall be revoked, and all the plaintiffs' claims corresponding to the revoked part shall be revoked.

1.The following facts may be found either in dispute between the parties or in full view of Gap evidence 1 to 5 (including the number with which each number is attached; hereinafter the same shall apply), Eul evidence 6 to 9, and the whole purport of arguments as a result of a request for appraisal by the court of first instance to the appraiser F of the court for appraisal:

Plaintiff

A1) On August 7, 2013, at around 19:50 on August 19, 2013, a driver of a vehicle on the number-to-face (G) insured by the Defendant’s comprehensive motor vehicle insurance, driving the said vehicle in the vicinity of the steering quarter of the coast of Chonam-dong, Seonam-dong, Sii-si, and was owned by the Plaintiff A (hereinafter “Plaintiff A”).

2) The instant accident was caused by the shocking accident (hereinafter “instant accident”).

2) After the instant accident, Plaintiff A’s vehicle repair business was repaired at the Incheon Service Center, KoreaMM, and the Defendant paid KRW 4,886,640 as insurance money.

3) 원고 A 차량의 주요 수리 내용은 백패널 교환, 트렁크바닥과 리어사이드맴버 판금 등이다. 나. 원고 B 1) 피고의 자동차종합보험에 가입된 I 차량 운전자가 2013. 7. 24. 18:05경 울산 울주군 온산읍 당월리에 있는 세진중공업 앞 도로에서 위 차량을 운전하다가 원고 B 소유 J 그랜저 승용차(이하 원고 B 차량이라고 한다)를 충격하는 사고가 발생하였다

(이하 이 사건 제2 사고라고 한다). 2) 이 사건 제2 사고 후 원고 B 차량은 자동차수리업체인 현대자동차 울산서비스센터에서 수리되었고, 피고는 수리비 14,434,000원을 보험금으로 지급하였다. 3) 원고 B 차량의 주요 수리 내용은 프론트 사이드맴버와 좌측 프론트 휀더 교환, 휠하우스와 카울패널 판금 등이다.

C. On June 28, 2013, at around 18:50 on June 28, 2013, the Plaintiff C-1’s driver was driving the said vehicle at the entrance of the Pyeongtaek-si B-dong tunnel, and was seated by Plaintiff C-owned.