1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. Basic facts

1. Matters referred to a competition;

(a) Project name: Selection of a person entrusted with the collection and transportation of household wastes in Seocheon-gun;

C. The period of entrustment: April 1, 2015 to December 31, 2016 (21 months)

(d) Project budget: Total amount of 5,800,263,840 won;

2. Method of concluding a contract: A contract by negotiation; and

4. Period of public notice: January 16, 2015 to February 25, 2015 (40 days)

7. Evaluation of proposals and determination of potential concessionaires;

A. 1) The evaluation of proposals and the selection of a person eligible for negotiation through negotiations (Article 43 of the Enforcement Decree of the Act on Contracts to Which a Local Government Is a Party): In accordance with the detailed evaluation criteria set by our Gun based on the "Rules 2 (No. 5, 2015) of the Ministry of the Interior (No. 2015), the evaluation of proposals for technical capacity (project performance and technical proposal) and price (no. 20 points : 100 points), the evaluation score of technical capability and price score of 70 points shall be selected as an eligible person to negotiate if there is no person whose aggregate scores are at least 70 points. 2) The second announcement shall be made if there is no person whose aggregate scores are at least 70 points.

3) The negotiation order shall be determined by the highest score of the comprehensive score from among the eligible negotiating persons, and where there are two or more same proposers with the same comprehensive score, the proposer with higher technical ability evaluation score shall be the first priority, and where the technical ability evaluation score is the same, it shall be determined by drawing lots. A. The Defendant will bid on January 16, 2015 on the selection of a person entrusted with the collection and transportation of household wastes in Seocheon-gun, Seocheon-gun. (hereinafter “instant bid”).

The notice was given, and its main contents are as follows (hereinafter “instant public notice of tender”).

B. According to the detailed evaluation items of the proposal and the allocation limit according to the public announcement of the instant case, the environmental relationship and the violation of labor-related laws during the new delivery evaluation are subject to the disposition of business suspension or penalty surcharge due to the violation of the Wastes Control Act within the last two years as of the date of public announcement.