1. The part against the defendant in the judgment of the court of first instance against the defendant is revoked, and the plaintiff who falls under the above part is against the defendant B.

1. Basic facts

A. The parties’ status relationship 1) Defendant B was the 17th proportional representative National Assembly member from 2004 to 2008, but the 18th proportional representative member was elected in the election of the 19th National Assembly member from April 11, 2012, and Defendant C was the 19th National Assembly member from the 19th National Assembly member who was elected in the election of the 19th National Assembly member from April 11, 2012, and Defendant C was elected as the 6th Yeongdeungpo-gu National Assembly member from the 19th National Assembly member from the 2004 to the 2005th National Assembly member from the 17th local election, and the 10th National Assembly member from the 17th National Assembly member from the 17th National Assembly member from the 10th National Assembly member from the 2010 to the 10th 7th 7th 7th 7th 2010 National Assembly member from the 2010 National Assembly member from the 17th 10.

B. Defendant B’s distribution of news materials, etc. 1) The Plaintiff informed the reporter in 2012 that “Defendant B provided money and valuables under the pretext of preparation,” in relation to news gathering, and that “Defendant B provided money and valuables to the voters of local constituency at the time of the 18th National Assembly election campaign for the 19th National Assembly member in March 5, 2012, the 19th National Assembly member election.” Defendant B offered money and valuables to voters at the time of the 2008 National Assembly member’s election for the 19th National Assembly member, which was before the 19th National Assembly member election for the 2008 National Assembly member, the article was published. 2) At the time of the 2008 National Assembly member, Defendant B, who was willing to receive the F Party’s official election for the 19th National Assembly member election for the 19th National Assembly member election for the 19th National Assembly member election for the 19th National Assembly member election, was distributed as follows.

“B.”.