1. Defendants A, B, and A, Inc., and Oyang Ships Co., Ltd., Oyang Ships Co., Ltd., and D, jointly with the Plaintiff.

1. Facts recognized;

(a) The front wharf of the Han-dong Vessel Repair Station in the Incheon Southern Port shall be located at the place where a barge carrying construction materials or carrying a crick is anchored or mooring, and many barge mooring in the middle, middle, third and mooring, and mooring location was changed from time to time according to the port of entry of the barge.

B. From January 2, 2014, E, a barge, anchored from around 2, 2014 to F, the port side was moored to F; the port side was moored to G while the mooring line was moored to F. H was mooring to the port side, and the port side was mooring to F.

C. Around 17:00 on January 4, 2014, F, which was mooring between H and E, was moved forward to obtain repair, the E-line J was at anchoring and mooring the mooring line on the left side of H, but did not anchor on the left side of H.

G headK on the same day temporarily mooring at the vicinity while L departs from the port and mooring at the port of E after the departure of L, and the mooring situation of the barge at the same time is as follows:

E. At around 19:30 on January 4, 2014, H Line M depart without connecting I and E.

F. Ultimately, E and G, other than the mooring line between the two barges, left the steering line or a fixed device, was irrelevant to that of the Plaintiff, which led to an accident in which G spinbane owned by the Plaintiff, and thereby, the cement structure of the spin wharf and the steel-frame passage, etc. were damaged (hereinafter “instant accident”).

G. Defendant A, B, and E Co., Ltd. are the owner of G; Defendant C’s owner; Defendant Obyang Ship Co., Ltd.; and Defendant Obyang Ship and D are the owner of H; the Defendants are the users of each owned ship.

[Ground of recognition] Facts without dispute, Gap evidence 2-1 to 25, evidence 3-1 to 3, evidence 5-1 to 3, evidence 7-1, 2-2 and the purport of the whole pleadings

2. Defendant A, B, and.