1. All appeals filed by the plaintiffs are dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal are assessed against the Plaintiffs.

Purport of claim and appeal

(b).

1. Facts recognized;

A. The status of the parties (1) Plaintiff D and Defendant E, H, K, and N (hereinafter “Defendant students”) were students who were enrolled in the fourth and fourth grade of the Seoul R Elementary School (hereinafter “instant elementary school”) in 2016.

(2) Plaintiff A and B are the parents of Plaintiff D, and Defendant F and G are the parents of Defendant E, Defendant L and M are the parents of Defendant H, Defendant L and M, Defendant P and Q are the parents of Defendant K, Defendant N’s parents, and Defendant N (hereinafter “Defendant students”).

(3) As the mother of Plaintiff C, Plaintiff C raises Plaintiff D on behalf of his parents.

B. The Defendant student’s harmful act (1) from April 2016 to the same year

5. By December 24, 200, Plaintiff D continued and repeated with the horses, such as Plaintiff D’s et al. or head from time to time, and Plaintiff D’s et al., “Namer, swine,” and “head activation,” etc., in the sports fields, meal service time, and summer hours, etc., which were seen to have become known to the school teachers, etc.,

(2) Around June 2016, the Defendant student complained against the fact that the team to which Defendant N belongs was unable to be sealed in the team to which Plaintiff D belongs.

Accordingly, on April 2016, the Defendant students suffered from Plaintiff D’s physical body several times in a way that the Defendant left Plaintiff D with a defect in the occupation time, and left Plaintiff D’s playground as an elementary school playground of this case and returned to each other after leaving Plaintiff D.

(hereinafter “instant 2 harmful act.” D. The instant 1 harmful act and each of the instant 1 harmful acts are “each of the instant harmful acts.”

(1) Disposition against Defendant students (1) The Autonomous Committee on Countermeasures against School Violence in this case (hereinafter “instant autonomous committee”) held a meeting on June 8, 2016 to recognize the fact of the instant 1 harmful act by holding a meeting, and to the Defendant students, the Act on the Prevention of and Countermeasures against School Violence (hereinafter “School Violence Prevention Act”).